How are you doing now?

(0) 讚！ | frivolous

The speed is really slow. Around the 10th of May, our submission to Angew was rejected and recommended to be transferred to AS for review. We waited for 4 months before receiving any news. There were a total of 3 reviewers, but only 2 provided feedback. It is estimated that the first reviewer left. Both reviewers gave around 5%, and the editor gave us three weeks to make revisions. We spent 10 days revising, and after submitting the revised version, it took about 15 days for acceptance.

(0) 讚！ | syk1309

May I ask what are the requirements for WB and PCR raw data for this magazine? Do the objectives and internal references need to be developed simultaneously? Is a melting curve graph required for PCR?

(0) 讚！ | LM

Just checked the submission number, based on an acceptance rate of 20%, the number of articles to be published this year should increase to 3000. It is estimated that the impact factor will be 13 next year.

(1) 讚！ | FelixHI

Three reviewers, all in the top 15% of minor revisions, provided professional and helpful feedback. The editor requested a major revision within two months. After revising, the status changed to "Reviewer request completed" after a week, but then reverted back to "Under review" the next day. It is possible that only two reviewers provided feedback, and the editor is waiting for the third opinion. Best of luck to everyone with their submissions!

2024.09.12 Submitted
2024.09.27 Under review
2024.10.11 Revision request
2024.10.24 Submission of revised version
2024.10.30 Reviewer request completed
2024.10.31 Under review
2024.11.11 Recommended for publication pending satisfactory revisions (format issue)
2024.11.11 Submission of revised version
2024.11.12 Accepted for publication without change

(0) 讚！ | FelixHI

Hello, I wanted to ask, when the reviews come back, there are several top percentile reviewers. Do we look at the last one, which is this one: "What do you anticipate your overall rating (a mean of importance, novelty and scholarly presentation) would be if the requested revisions are adequately addressed?"

(0) 讚！ | Caroline2255

Before submitting, I read a lot of experiences, and now I want to share my very bumpy submission experience. It took nearly 6 months, with battles against 5 reviewers.

2024.06.21 submitted to journal
2024.06.28 with editor under review
2024.08.22 major revision, 4 reviewers, 2 rejected with 15%, 1 with 30%, editor requested the 4th reviewer to arbitrate at 5%
2024.09.13 submission of revision
2024.09.13 with editor under review (during arbitration, RRC sent back to UR once)
2024.10.23 minor revision, added 1 reviewer for second arbitration at 30%, 1 reviewer lost, 2 accepted, rejections remained rejected
2024.11.05 submission of revision, with editor under review, must say editor was very supportive
2024.11.11 acceptance without change (doubtful rejections remained rejected)

Wishing everyone's articles are successfully accepted in the end!

(0) 讚！ | zy965

Sending emails doesn't make much sense either, my first and second reviews are both close to 2 months, the first review took a full 2 months, the second review 45 days, the third review just left on the 5th, and I don't know when they will be back, it's just slow.

(0) 讚！ | zy965

Recently life sciences have been moving particularly slowly.
Submitted on 8.26
With editor on 9.9
Under review on 11.6

(0) 讚！ | alarui

Have you received the feedback on your manuscript review?

(0) 讚！ | 我勒个去哪

Hello, how much is the layout fee?

(0) 讚！ | nwu.pirlo

It has been almost 2 months since "under review" status, and there is still no news. It's too slow. Should I send an email to inquire about this situation? 
Submitted on 8.27
Under review on 9.16

(0) 讚！ | 我勒个去哪

2024.10.15 Manuscript Submitted
2024.10.19 With Editor
2024.10.23 Under Review
Hope everything goes smoothly!

(0) 讚！ | lzj1997

Has any friend encountered a situation where they have not been notified to pay after proofreading, it has been a week since proofreading, but they have not been notified to pay;
I have not received the author's confirmation email, and there is nothing in the article management...

(0) 讚！ | 没什么特别之处

Maybe the editing process will be faster if we follow the suggestion of transferring the material from AM.

(1) 讚！ | finnhan

Good luck to the host! I also recently applied to AS, and it seems like you are really fast. Is it because the material direction is faster? I applied for the biosensing direction.

(1) 讚！ | 扶摇直上瀚宇之外

2024.10.28 Manuscript Submitted
2024.11.1 With Editor
2024.11.2 Reject

(1) 讚！ | 扶摇直上瀚宇之外

My review feedback hasn't come back yet, it's been two and a half months, I'm freaking out.

(0) 讚！ | 阿汤哥

I am in the same situation, it has been a week since the proof was submitted, but I have not received any notification for payment, nor have I received the email confirming from the author.

(0) 讚！ | 没什么特别之处

10.28/29 major revisions
4 reviewers, 1 in the top 5% and 3 in the top 15%
Wish me luck, wish everyone luck.

(1) 讚！ | finnhan

Are you there, OP? What was the result? How many days did it take for the RRC to give you the result? Is it a major or minor issue?

(0) 讚！ | finnhan

2024.8.28 First submitted
2024.9.17 with editor
2024.9.18 under review
2024.10.6 rrc
2024.10.7 major revision, 3 reviewers, cannot see percentage, evaluation is relatively neutral leaning towards positive, given 3 weeks for revisions
2024.10.27 revision submitted
2024.10.28 under review
2024.11.4 rrc
2024.11.5 accept Thank the editor and reviewers.

(1) 讚！ | dusitn

10.7 submitted to AM
10.8 transferred to AS
10.11 submitted to AS
10.14 under review
10.24 rrc

The review comments came back a little too quickly, I'm feeling anxious!! I hope for a positive outcome. To all my fellow comrades, I will come back and share if I am successful. Wish me luck, and wish everyone good luck~~~~~~

(1) 讚！ | finnhan

May I ask how long it usually takes to receive a decision after RRC?

(0) 讚！ | AIR357

Payment is required in the author-confirm sent after receiving.

(0) 讚！ | zlf1314