First review 30 days, second review 40 days, followed by minor revisions 10 days, the overall results are not bad, thank you to the editing reviewers

(0) 讚！ | wkc

Recording the most difficult submission process
First submission
2023/9/7 submitted
2023/9/25 rejected: rejected with minor revisions, editor gave rejection

Disagreed with the first reviewer's opinion, argued back, second submission
2024/1/24 submitted
2024/2/20 reject and resubmission: rejected with minor revisions, editor gave rejection for resubmission (3-month deadline)

Third submission
2024/5/14 submitted (answered reviewer's questions, not much additional experiments, delayed for two months)
2024/6/4 accepted (suddenly accepted…

(0) 讚！ | letpub李

**
1. How many days after editing is the submission sent for review?
2. Will the status be updated after submission for review?

**

(0) 讚！ | gxlshenlan

I have been displaying this status for 17 days now. How is the progress of your article?

(0) 讚！ | 小羽羽

I would like to ask where can I check the status of my submitted article in this journal

(0) 讚！ | 想要运气好点

2024/2/15 submitted
2024/2/16 Associate Editor Assigned (email notification)
2024/2/23 under review
2024/3/15 major revision (email notification)
2024/4/18 revision submitted (email notification)
2024/4/19 revision (minor formatting changes)
2024/4/22 revision submitted
2024/4/22 accepted (email notification)
Overall, I am quite satisfied

(0) 讚！ | letpub李

2024.01.06 Submission
2024.01.08 Assigned to Associate Editor
2024.02.05 Major Revision
2024.02.28 Revised
2024.03.14 Major Revision
2024.03.26 Revised
2024.04.01 Minor Revision
2024.04.02 Revised
2024.04.02 Accepted

(1) 讚！ | 生化环材学科交叉=失业

Go check the status at the publish center

(0) 讚！ | angle6321

The specific status of the manuscript can be viewed on the Publish Center page after logging in

(0) 讚！ | angle6321

Submitted on February 25th, there was a small error. After returning, there was no way to resubmit. I couldn't submit it again. They said to send an email with the modifications, but where can I make the changes? The submission system is too poor. No way out. I resubmitted on March 4th, and on March 5th it showed that it had been assigned to an editor and was "Under Review". In reality, it is still with the associate editor after 2 weeks. How did the person with an average period of one month do it??????

(0) 讚！ | 随喻而安

March 11th revised
March 15th accepted, and received request to sign ACS Journal Publishing Agreement
The overall submission process was less than a month, a total of 27 days. Thumbs up to the efficient editorial team at ACS Catalysis

(0) 讚！ | angle6321

The manuscript was first submitted to JACS, with one minor revision and one rejection from the reviewers, leading to the decision of rejection by the editor. Following revisions based on the reviewers' comments, the manuscript was then submitted to Angew, with two modifications suggested by the reviewers and one recommendation for resubmission, resulting in acceptance for resubmission by the editor. However, the reviewer who recommended resubmission still expressed dissatisfaction with the mechanistic aspects of the work. Despite this, the other two reviewers in the second round of review agreed that the work had an importance and novelty exceeding 20%. It is possible that the editor was too strict or that Angew receives a high volume of submissions and thus may reject more. The manuscript will now be resubmitted to ACS Catalysis.
Submitted on February 16th.
Assigned to Associate Editor, Prof. T. Brent Gunnoe on February 19th.
External peer review completed around February 21st.
Received feedback on March 6th, with one reviewer recommending direct publication and one recommending minor revisions.
Hoping for a smooth acceptance to finally conclude the stressful process of manuscript submission

(11) 讚！ | angle6321

It seems that the quality is constantly declining, and many articles have shallower catalytic mechanisms than before. I don't know the reason, but I feel it is not worth investing anymore

(21) 讚！ | 778899catalysis

The status of ACS can be viewed in Instructions & Forms, and the initial page will only show "Under Review"

(0) 讚！ | 生化环材学科交叉=失业

Friend, how long did it take for you to submit? I submitted 20 days ago and it still hasn't been reviewed

(0) 讚！ | 毕业毕业毕业qqq

My article has been with the associate editor for almost two weeks, but there has been no progress. The status still shows pending his next assessment. Why is the efficiency so slow, help!

(0) 讚！ | 毕业毕业毕业qqq

Received publishing editor letter and ACS modification system link on January 14, 2024;
Completed system check and submitted on January 16, 2024;
Online ASAP on January 17, 2024

(0) 讚！ | 松小达

November 7, 2023 Submitted to ACS Catalysis;
November 10, 2023 Under review by editors;
December 6, 2023 Received reviewer comments, minor revision, major revision, conducted additional experiments for over two weeks, and ran some theoretical calculations;
January 2, 2024 Submitted response in the system;
January 5, 2024 Received official acceptance letter

(1) 讚！ | 松小达

I also noticed that it has been submitted for review, but I'm not sure which day exactly. Thank you for letting me know!

(0) 讚！ | 生化环材学科交叉=失业

Update submitted on 01.26

(0) 讚！ | VVV小墨

01.26 Submission, no email notification, see in submission center

(0) 讚！ | VVV小墨

Bro, your paper has been submitted for review, give me a kick

(0) 讚！ | 生化环材学科交叉=失业

I invested at 1.08, and it still hasn't been submitted for review at 1.23

(0) 讚！ | VVV小墨

2024.01.08 Submitted for review
2024.01.09 Assigned to Associate Editor
2024.01.23 Not yet sent for review

(0) 讚！ | VVV小墨

2024.01.06 Submission
2024.01.08 Assigned to Associate Editor
Still not reviewed yet, urgent urgent urgent urgent urgent urgent urgent urgent! I am the Urgent King!

(2) 讚！ | 生化环材学科交叉=失业