Still pending review to date! It is still in "with editor" status, from 04.19 until now! However, after seeing the comment on the 67th floor mentioning the possibility of self-review by the editor, I hope that after waiting for over a month, it can finally be successfully submitted for review through editor self-review!

(0) 讚！ | lffzyr

I didn't know there was such a thing as self-editing! It's the first time I've heard of it! It's enlightening! Hopefully it's a good thing!

(1) 讚！ | lffzyr

The previous article, which had not been peer-reviewed before, was self-reviewed for 2 months by the editor before being rejected with encouragement to resubmit. Due to the difficulty of making changes, it was submitted to Friction International.

This time, encountering the same editor, after self-reviewing for 2 months, the editor did not reject it but asked for revisions and resubmission. The reason for the rejection and resubmission of the previous article was also explained. The editor is very lovely.

Editor at Wear is very professional and patient, and the questions raised are also very professional. They do not reject articles without reason, but the time cost is higher. Students who are eager to publish should consider carefully

(1) 讚！ | 小材机

My manuscript was revised on December 17, 2023, and was reviewed by one of the reviewers on December 22. The other reviewer accepted the review, but as of May 14, 2024, it has not been completed (almost 5 months), and I have sent two reminder emails in between. Sigh, I wonder if the reviewer is dead

(0) 讚！ | 麦田里的汤姆猫

It's so cool, my submission was made on August 23, 2023, returned for revision on December 17, and now it's May 14, 2024 and the reviewers still haven't finished reviewing the revised manuscript......... It's been a total of 9 months

(0) 讚！ | 麦田里的汤姆猫

The submission period should be 3 and a half months, which is not bad and quite smooth

(0) 讚！ | rockrider

2024-01-30 submit
2024-02-01 with editor
2024-02-03 under review
2024-03-03 major revision
2024-04-01 under review
2024-05-13 accept

(0) 讚！ | rockrider

Can anyone guide me on how to check the status of submitted articles?

(0) 讚！ | 阿里巴巴

However, just checked the status updates downstairs, most of them require updating the status with editor after a with editor submission. Is this a common practice for journals? What does this step mean?

(0) 讚！ | lffzyr

Still with editor status so far, it has been submitted for a month.
2024.04.10 submitted to journal
2024.04.14 with editor
2024.04.19 with editor (updated once)
Still with editor status

(0) 讚！ | lffzyr

Has it been submitted for review? Hasn't it been submitted yet today?

(1) 讚！ | 风云随心

2024-04-29 submit
2024-05-03 with editor
2024-05-10 with editor
At this rate, I will have to wait until the end of May. The last article I submitted, "wear," was in November 2023, and after a round of revisions and reviews, it was accepted on May 4, 2024. I feel like the review process for this article is slower than the previous one, as the last one was with the editor in just ten days

(0) 讚！ | 风云随心

Could you please explain what questions the editor has raised? I have been waiting for a long time for feedback from the editor, but have not received any results yet

(0) 讚！ | Dora130

2024-4-19 submit
2024-04-23 with editor
2024-04-26 with editor
2024-05-07 reject
The editor is very professional, and the rejection feedback is undeniable

(0) 讚！ | 阿啊啊啊

The paper has been submitted for review. One reviewer has finished reviewing it on April 20th, but the other reviewer has not finished reviewing it yet

(0) 讚！ | halloly

With editor means that the editor has not reviewed your manuscript yet, and you are in queue behind other manuscripts assigned to the same editor. The allocation of editors is different for each person depending on their chosen topic. Additionally, the number of submissions for each topic varies greatly, so some people may see progress faster while others may experience delays. There is no universal meaning to what "with editor" signifies. Some manuscripts may be under review with the editor for three months, while others may not pass the editor's evaluation after three months. Some may be rejected by the editor in a day, while others may be sent for further review within two days. If you want clarification, it's best to directly email the editor

(1) 讚！ | 风云随心

Has the revised submission been sent back now? Has it been accepted? I don't know if it's the American student activities that delayed this journal so much in April

(0) 讚！ | 风云随心

With an editor, it is possible that they will carefully review the work, provide some feedback for revisions, and then submit it for review (the editor will act as a reviewer first

(1) 讚！ | 后面没有路可走

The likelihood of my submission being rejected seems to be increasing day by day. Haha

(0) 讚！ | lffzyr

This is such a waste of time, why is the processing speed so slow?!

(0) 讚！ | lffzyr

Submitted to the journal on 10th April 2024, status changed to "With Editor" on 14th April. Updated once on 19th April but still "With Editor". Now it's 30th April and still "With Editor". I would like to ask if it has been sent for review or not? (Really hope it has been sent for review, just that the status hasn't changed to "Under Review"). Why is the handling of manuscripts in this journal so slow?!

(0) 讚！ | lffzyr

Unbelievably slow! Unbelievably slow! Submissions from others for 2024 have been accepted, but mine submitted on August 23, 2023 is still under review (R1

(0) 讚！ | 麦田里的汤姆猫

I submitted an article to the editor and waited for two months, but it was rejected without even being sent out for external review. However, another article was reviewed externally in about ten days and was accepted. I think the longer the waiting time, the lower the value in the editor's mind

(1) 讚！ | 风云随心

2024.04.10 submitted to the journal
2024.04.14 with editor
2024.04.19 with editor (rescheduled)
How long does it usually take for a journal to be with the editor? Is there a relationship between the length of time with editor and the likelihood of acceptance? The waiting process is too agonizing

(0) 讚！ | lffzyr

Thank you! When I submitted the first draft, it was only in "with editor" status for less than a day before it became "under review." I thought that the revised draft would be processed faster, but it has been in "with editor" status for 11 days already... I'm feeling extremely anxious waiting

(0) 讚！ | halloly