Can you please tell me why I cannot access the submission website? Were you submitting to this website at the time when you clicked on it?

(0) 讚！ | 犇777

The submission website of this journal has been inaccessible, are there any other websites available for submission?

(0) 讚！ | 犇777

May I ask where can I view the current status of the article?

(0) 讚！ | wyliu81

I currently have the status showing "Reviewers are selected." Does that mean it's for external review? Does anyone know?

(0) 讚！ | Giao博

The review speed is still relatively normal. However, after revisions, I wasted 2 months due to my own reasons and forgot to attach the response comments to the revised manuscript.

(0) 讚！ | cjcj

Can the author be added after the first review? It's not a very important author, just add them as a secondary author. I noticed that once the reply is submitted, the author information in the system cannot be changed

(0) 讚！ | DPPER

Very slow... in 10 months, nearly 70 reviewers were invited, one agreed to review, but did not submit comments for 9 months. The editor was very diligent, always helping to find a second reviewer. In the end, we had to voluntarily give up submitting to this journal (still very grateful that the editor did not give up on us), and switch to another journal. Recommendation: consider submitting papers with similar themes to this journal, and that can wait for a long time. If no reviewers are found within 1 month after submission, it is appropriate to send an email to the editor, otherwise the process will be longer

(0) 讚！ | 年轮

Any expert with experience in submitting contributions, please give me some guidance. Could it be that I didn't receive any confirmation email similar to "Sent to the Chief Editor," which has caused the progress to stall?

(0) 讚！ | wwwwaaaaa

Hello, the progress of my submission to this journal has also stalled. I would like to ask if you have a step called "Sent to the Chief Editor." I have been stuck at this step for 3 months

(0) 讚！ | wwwwaaaaa

2023-11-05 Manuscript Submission Confirm Mail - Sent
2023-11-06 Manuscript Submission Confirmed by author
2023-11-06 Preliminary Check Revise required
2023-11-11 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
2023-11-22 Preliminary Check OK
2023-11-22 Manuscript ID Renamed Confirm Mail - Sent
2023-11-22 Sent to the Chief Editor

(0) 讚！ | wwwwaaaaa

2023-04-14    Confirm Mail - Sent
2023-04-14    Confirmed by author
2023-04-28    Sent to 1 reviewer(s)
2023-04-28    Sent to 1 reviewer(s)
2023-06-08    under review
2023-08-25    Sent to 2 reviewer(s)
2023-08-25    Sent to 1 reviewer(s)
2023-09-22    Marginal / Major Change
2023-09-23    under review
2023-09-28    Revise Required
2023-10-09    Required to Reviewer 3
2023-10-23    Required to Reviewer 3
2023-10-24    Review Result    Marginal / Minor Change
2023-11-27    Sent to reviewer(s)    under review
This speed is so slow, one major revision, and still unsure if it will be accepted

(0) 讚！ | naughty.Boy

The journal's processing procedure is not standardized. The post-review channel for articles is not closed after the decision, resulting in papers that have already been accepted for final decision being rejected. Additionally, the journal editor refuses to communicate and selectively replies to emails. The speed of manuscript processing is highly dependent on luck. It is advised to be cautious when submitting.

(0) 讚！ | Goatling

Hello, may I ask if the status bar of this journal displays anything like "one reviewer agreed"? If not, it is indeed not possible to see how many reviewers have agreed to review.

(0) 讚！ | 年轮

Hello, may I ask if the status bar of this journal displays phrases like "one reviewer agreed"?

(0) 讚！ | 年轮

Very trashy, very slow, it took thirteen months for the first review, and no response was received no matter how many emails were sent in between.
I don't know what this editor is doing, it's very slow, four reviewers,
The editor is very irresponsible.
It's really not worth it.

(4) 讚！ | piyangyang

Have you tried closing the browser and restarting it? I encountered a similar issue in another journal and restarting solved it.

(0) 讚！ | Jack_ABC

Slow, super slow. I submitted in March 2021, and it hasn't come back for the first review yet. I will withdraw the submission next week. It's garbage. When I submitted it, they required at least 7 self-citations and the manuscript format is unique. I submitted it before I graduated, and it's been half a year since I started working, and it still hasn't been reviewed. It's garbage. They have already put me on their blacklist.

(1) 讚！ | Coco_9354

It is civil engineering, with a focus on structures.

(0) 讚！ | 大依旧

Dear experts, my review is finished, but there was a problem with the system when I tried to submit the revised manuscript. When I entered the system to submit the manuscript, it didn't show up. I don't know what happened. Has anyone else encountered a similar situation, either students or teachers? Please give me some advice. This thesis is my graduation requirement, so thank you all in advance!!!

(0) 讚！ | 大依旧

2021-12-12 Manuscript Submission Confirmed by author
2021-12-19 Preliminary Check OK
2022-02-21 Review Result Average / Major Change
2022-03-16 One Review Completed/Two Reviewers
2022-04-11 Review Result Average / Major Change
2022-04-12 Final Review Revise Required
2022-05-12 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
2022-05-13 Review Result Average / Accept
2022-10-24 Final Review Accepted
2022-11-01 Proofs in Progress
2022-11-03 On-line Journal Published

(0) 讚！ | flyingbird316

The review process is very slow.

(0) 讚！ | Ben_

It took 11 months, I don't know how long it will take to retrieve.

(0) 讚！ | linjiaxiang

2022-07-28 Review Result Good / Major Change
2022-07-29 Review Changed to 550
2022-08-10 Final Review Revise Required
2022-08-18 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
2022-08-18 Re-review Required to Reviewer 6
2022-08-18 Re-review Required to Reviewer 7
2022-08-18
2022-08-25 Review Result Good / Accept

(0) 讚！ | linjiaxiang

May I ask on which date will it be published? Thank you very much.

(0) 讚！ | Cage Sun

Dust has settled! After 13 months of review, it has finally been accepted! Sigh, maybe I will continue to submit in the future, but I can only choose articles that I'm not in a hurry for.

(0) 讚！ | Cage Sun