Slow down to the point of explosion, it has been half a month since the status is With Editor

(0) 讚！ | huangweihong

A very good soil science journal with high language requirements, not easy to publish, took half a year repeatedly! Fortunately lucky!

(0) 讚！ | DAN K

Finally accepted today! Thanks to editor Huang!

(0) 讚！ | 快乐加减除哈哈哈

Submitted on September 16th, revised twice, it has been 8 days since the second revision, still in "with editor". The quality of the journal is quite good, but the speed is really slow. Comrades who are eager to graduate and apply for funding, please consider carefully!

(0) 讚！ | 快乐加减除哈哈哈

The top spot is finally ours in 2023, aiming towards Zone 1 in the future!

(390) 讚！ | 明镜止水

Received at Editorial Office
22 Aug 2023
Article revised
31 Oct 2023
Article accepted for publication
1 Dec 2023

(0) 讚！ | microeco

Why is such a good journal not in the first tier? At least it should be in the second tier top.

(383) 讚！ | 明镜止水

The first submission was rejected due to my own issues, but the editor showed interest in the paper. The suggestion was to revise and resubmit. After resubmitting, the paper was sent to two external reviewers, who provided constructive feedback. After major revisions, the paper was sent back again for language editing and proofreading due to language issues and excessive length. Finally, it was accepted. The process was delayed by two months due to my own reasons. The editor was diligent and responsible, and the questions and suggestions proposed were beneficial. This is the first SCI paper during my doctoral studies.

(4) 讚！ | zhanDiudiu

The reviewers were not found, so it was rejected.

(0) 讚！ | 斑马景茶

Hello, I would like to ask, on 5.20, were you asked to "modify the format and polish the language"? Did you polish it again according to the website provided by the editor?

(0) 讚！ | xiaomm

2022.3.13 Submission
2022.4.17 Revision
2020.5.4 Revised
2022.5.8 Editor mentioned formatting issues
2022.6.5 External review
2022.8.5 External review, one reviewer accepted the submission (no comments provided yet)
2022.9.30 Sent an email to the editor, editor invited 10 reviewers, one accepted the submission
2022.10.25 Received one review
2022.11.10 Sent an email to the editor, editor didn't wait for the second review, added my own comments for revision
2022.12.11 Revised
2022.12.13 Accepted
Overall, the process was slow, but the quality of the article has greatly improved (PS: Every time they mention a 32% plagiarism rate, I suspect the editor made a mistake in the plagiarism report).

(0) 讚！ | dk仙凡

My situation is exactly the same as your process. I submitted it on July 13th, and the "under review" date has been continuously changing. I wonder if there is any hope of being accepted like this?

(0) 讚！ | 扶苏公子

The review process is just too slow.

(0) 讚！ | 扶苏公子

10/16/2022 after more than 8 months of tossing and turning, it was finally accepted after 3 rounds of revisions. This magazine has a long publication cycle.

(0) 讚！ | Nick

8/23/2022 rrc - No translation available as it seems to be a code or specific reference.

8/24/2022 under review - An additional reviewer has been added for editing.

8/25/2022 rrc - No translation available as it seems to be a code or specific reference.

8/29/2022 minor revisions.

9/6/2022 returned after making the necessary changes.

9/7/2022 with editor.

(0) 讚！ | Nick

May I ask what does "With editor中间日期变了一次" mean in English?

(0) 讚！ | 辣条哥

What does it mean that the date in the middle changed once?

(0) 讚！ | 辣条哥

2021.4.17 Submission
2021.5.20 Format modification, language polishing
2021.6.24 Under review
2021.7.19 Under review
Intermittent updates under review
2022.1.19 Minor review
2022.3.1 Revised
2022.4.30 Major revise/minor revise/moderate revise, one of them with a new reviewer
2022.6.9 Revised
2022.7.11 Moderate revision
2022.7.19 Revised
2022.8.5 Completed-accept
The submission process was long and arduous, and it was urgent for graduation. However, I am very grateful for the suggestions and help provided by the editor and reviewers. They were very objective, and I learned a lot during the process. My first SCI publication was successfully published!

(2) 讚！ | 解纠纠

7/23/2022 under review. After the minor revisions are made, it still needs to be reviewed by two reviewers. Speechless...

(0) 讚！ | Nick

7/22/2022 with editor has been over half a month.

(0) 讚！ | Nick

On 7.8, the edited content that needed to be revised was returned. On 7.9, it was successfully received! This time, the handling was very fast. Other than being a little slow, this magazine is pretty good overall.

(0) 讚！ | liuRC

1/31/2022 Submission
1/4/2022 Major revision with editor for one month, under review for about one month
15/5/2022 Return
26/6/2022 Minor revision still under review for about one month
5/7/2022 Return

(10) 讚！ | Nick

Received an email on June 29th. Both reviewers said that the suggested issues have been addressed and recommended acceptance. However, the editor provided additional suggestions and requested language editing.

(0) 讚！ | liuRC

The editor is too slow, my minor repair has been returned for 1 month, and it has not been handled yet.

(0) 讚！ | liuRC