Just waiting without urging or any movement

(0) 讚！ | Carambola.

Submission on 21st September 2023
First reviewer accepts the submission on 1st October 2023
First reviewer completes review on 16th October 2023
Second reviewer found on 27th March 2024, approximately every half month inviting a reviewer
Second reviewer completes review on 28th March 2024
Major revisions on 11th April 2024
Revised on 19th April 2024
Minor revisions on 29th April 2024
Revised on 30th April 2024
Acceptance on 3rd May 2024

(0) 讚！ | 满眼是你满是遗憾

The first SCI, lasting 9 months. I knew before I submitted it that this journal was very slow. Because I like it, I was prepared mentally. I hope everyone can submit to the journal they like. I was very anxious and distressed at that time. After reading the sharing from predecessors, I felt it would make me feel a little more at ease. So I tried to write in detail as much as possible for everyone's reference. Wish everyone smooth scientific research

(0) 讚！ | 学长-YLU

2023.11.07 (Second reviewer completed review, a total of 2 reviewers completed the review)
2023.11.10  Required review completed
2023.11.20 Review complete
2023.11.30 Major revise (Editor's deadline is 2024.02.18)
2024.02.17 Revision submitted (The two reviewers were very professional, providing about 60 comments in total, mainly positive. The editor also provided some comments. Both reviewers mentioned language issues, so the paper was basically rewritten and resubmitted)
2024.02.24 Under review
2024.03.28 Required review completed
2024.03.28 Review Completed
2024.04.05 Accept

(0) 讚！ | 学长-YLU

Sorry, I posted it in the wrong place

(0) 讚！ | 学长-YLU

2023.07.07 Submitted to journal
2023.07.11 Notice to change format, did not write in small font size and double spacing, information not clear at that time.
2023.07.16 Submitted to journal
2023.07.23 With editor (this status lasted for a month at that time, didn't dare to rush)
2023.08.23 Under review
2023.09.07 (First reviewer completed review)
2023.09.23 Under review (Reminded 3 times in between, once a month, emails sent through the system, felt like it didn't work, editor did not reply to me)
2023.10.23 Under review (This status changed 3 times, originally the editor was continuously looking for reviewers, first time found 4 reviewers, invited 2 reviewers every month, a total of 8 reviewers were found

(0) 讚！ | 学长-YLU

I submitted on the 2nd of April. Was there any update between then and the 18th of April when it was accepted, or did it just take two months? I'm also the editor and scanned his hand to make minor changes for me

(0) 讚！ | hkwhkwhkw

One-time overhaul, directly accepted, the fastest article!

(0) 讚！ | 海子

August has come to a successful end. After undergoing two major revisions, the editors and reviewers were very meticulous and provided insightful suggestions, which greatly improved my work. Grateful!

(0) 讚！ | 兔努力

Hello, poster, do I need to upload the original data and data processing process when submitting to this journal?

(0) 讚！ | WJysan5009

2024-01-31 accept

(0) 讚！ | hehe2333323

2023-09-30 submitted
2023-10-04 with editor
2023-10-19 urged via system
2023-10-20 urged editor directly
2023-10-21 with editor
2023-10-22 under review (1 reviewer invited, 1 accepted)
2023-10-23 under review (3 invited, 2 accepted)
2023-11-07 under review (3 invited, 2 accepted, 1 completed)
2023-11-10 RRC (3 invited, 2 accepted, 2 completed)
2023-11-14 moderate revise
2023-12-09 revision submitted
2023-12-12 with editor
2023-12-13 under review
2024-01-04 moderate revision
2024-01-07 revision submitted
2024-01-09 with editor
2024-01-16 under review
2024-01-24 RRC

(11) 讚！ | hehe2333323

This journal is really slow, especially the first review. It took around 6 months to be published after two rounds of revisions, with a total time of nearly 9 months from submission to acceptance. However, the journal is very good!

(4) 讚！ | sunny206

You can directly message the editor-in-chief, and if the editor-in-chief sees the email, they will contact you directly as the managing editor. The first issue I submitted to this magazine in 2019, the managing editor was sick and eventually resigned. After waiting for 3 months in the editor's hands, I finally asked the editor-in-chief to find out the situation. In the end, I had no choice but to withdraw the submission and submitted it to Geoderma, which was accepted

(0) 讚！ | hehe2333323

The Soil Science Journal is really slow and makes people impatient. I suspect they only process once a week, or the environmental journal is faster. If possible, try suggesting the environmental journal

(0) 讚！ | zzx

It is not possible to contact directly. You don't even know who the responsible editor is. The magazine itself is slow, and submissions can only be urged through the system, which will be forwarded to the responsible editor

(0) 讚！ | hehe2333323

Family members, I have been looking for a reviewer for three months and haven't found one yet. I want to ask how can I contact the responsible editor. I urgently need it for graduation. Thank you

(0) 讚！ | 小农人

You can simply upload it separately

(0) 讚！ | hehe2333323

I would like to ask about the submission format of this journal - should the figures and tables be included in the main text, rather than uploaded separately?

(0) 讚！ | 泡泡有只猫

2023-12-13 under review

(0) 讚！ | hehe2333323

Feb 16, 2023 Submitted
Feb 26, 2023 under Review
Mar 16, 2023 under Review (I feel like I found the second reviewer)
Apr 23, 2023 Required reviews completed (I feel like the comments came back)
May 08, 2023 First review came back Major revisions
Jun 30, 2023 Returned to the first reviewer, in the meantime went home to get married, delayed for two months before returning
Aug 04, 2023 Second review comments returned, another major revision
Oct 02, 2023 Almost all discussions have been changed, almost gave up in the middle, but after battling with the supervisor, returned on time
Oct 09, 2023 Under Review, second review submitted
Nov 19, 2023 Second review came back, another major revision, mainly struggling with one original problem
Dec 07, 2023 Third review returned, made changes as per the editor's request, didn't stick to my own beliefs
Dec 10, 2023 with editor
Dec 17, 2023 One week later, website showed accept
Now just waiting for when it will be published online

(14) 讚！ | wangli

2023-12-09 revision submited

(0) 讚！ | hehe2333323

It has been two weeks, and the status of the editor remains unchanged. I heard it was slow before, but I didn't expect it to be this slow

(0) 讚！ | 小小小小小林

First Submission to STR, it was very fortunate that the article was accepted. The whole process from submission to acceptance took a total of 9 months, including a major revision and a minor revision. The majority of time was spent on finding reviewers, and the first round of Under Review lasted for four months. Although the time was passing, the status remained unchanged. After inquiring about the review status with the official customer service, the response was always waiting for the reviewers' feedback. The reviewers provided many constructive comments and suggestions on the article, greatly improving it. There were over 40 comments in the first review, and each response carefully addressed the reviewers' comments and revised the relevant sections. The editorial handling was very timely, compared to other journals in the field of soil science, the review process at STR is relatively slower, so patience is needed when submitting

(18) 讚！ | Earth Worker

11.8 submitted
Editor returned for formatting changes
11.16 with editor
11.17 under review (2 external reviewers, currently no agreement on peer review

(0) 讚！ | Gaven