10.26 Submission to Editor
11.15 Reviewer invited

(0) 讚！ | CoolChen

October 18th, All Reviews Completed.

(0) 讚！ | kkkkkyyyyy

September 5
September 9 under review
September 15 reviewer invited
September 23 under review

(0) 讚！ | kkkkkyyyyy

After submitting with the editor, if the status shows "decision in progress", does it mean the submission will be rejected?

(0) 讚！ | ecnulc

Can I continue to submit after the rejection of the editor?

(0) 讚！ | paper_king

Is it a explicit requirement of the journal that it cannot exceed 15%? I think the general requirement is usually below 20%.

(0) 讚！ | paper_king

Can I see the status "reviewer invited" in the submission status column?

(0) 讚！ | paper_king

Did you see the status of your reviewer invitation on the submission page?

(0) 讚！ | paper_king

Can you see the status of "invited" for your reviewer(s) on the submission page?

(0) 讚！ | paper_king

I submitted it in early July and it took half a month for the editor to review it, so just be patient.

(0) 讚！ | naivechildghc

May I ask how long it took for the change to occur later on?

(0) 讚！ | 八戒朱

This is really efficient.

(0) 讚！ | 八戒朱

It's been over half a month already, still "with editor", not sure if it will take a long time or just be rejected directly.

(0) 讚！ | 八戒朱

As one of the top journals in the field of remote sensing, RSE's reputation and article quality in recent years are widely recognized. After researching the topic for four to five years, despite being rejected two years ago, the editor-in-chief Marie Weiss provided constructive feedback and direction. After two years of effort, the submission was finally accepted by the editors and reviewers. Best wishes for the continued success of the journal!

There were a total of three reviewers, three rounds of revisions, with major revisions in the first two rounds and acceptance in the final round. Each round of review took 2-3 months, with the same amount of time given for revisions. The editor-in-chief and associate editors responded quickly after each submission, with changes typically made within a week. All three reviewers and the associate editors were professional and emphasized the innovation and rigor of the work. If these criteria were met, they would provide feedback to help improve the quality of the article in other aspects.

(1) 讚！ | 白羊屁孩儿

I apologize for my emotions and my youthful ignorance. I used to think that ideas and creativity were the core of a paper, but RSE has shown me that making it understandable to more people and conducting more detailed investigations and evidence are the true core of an article!

(0) 讚！ | Wcai

Just like me, haha. The reviewer's one sentence "Lack of innovation" really disappointed me.

(0) 讚！ | Wcai018

The chief editor's quick review is commendable. But those three reviewers, can you even read what was written? Are these rubbish articles in RSE approved by you? Not even looking at the methods section, making unwarranted comments? Do you really think you know it all? Do you think you're a big shot? And clearly Chinese, only focusing on your own circle and not those outside of it? What a top journal, more like a toilet, stinking to high heaven.

(0) 讚！ | Wcai018

Hello, may I ask where the resubmitted option is located?

(0) 讚！ | gggg

Jun. 01, 2024: Submitted to the Journal
Jun. 15, 2024: Reviewer Invited
Jun. 18, 2024: Under Review (6 invitations sent, 4 invitations accepted)
Jul. 13, 2024: Under Review (1/4)
Jul. 22, 2024: Under Review (2/4)
Jul. 24, 2024: Under Review (3/4)

(0) 讚！ | Cirrus

01 Jun 2024 Resubmitted
02 Jun 2024 With Editor
02 Jun 2024 Under Review
10 Jun 2024 Reviewer invited

The app shows that one reviewer has completed the second round of review. The two reviewers from the first round did not agree to review, so I am worried. I may need to invite new reviewers again.

(0) 讚！ | 依缘

5.26 Submitted to journal
5.28 With editor
5.29 Rejected, suggested for resubmission

(1) 讚！ | QAQ

6.17 Submitted to journal
6.19 Back to author, with editor
6.21 Reviewer invited
6.22 Under review 
6.25 Under review (Final acceptance by 2nd reviewer)
7.16 Reports from both reviewers have been submitted
8.1 Invited a new reviewer
8.5 New reviewer accepted
8.11 New reviewer submitted report Required reviews completed
8.12 Major revision
10.9 Submit the revised version
10.9 With Editor
10.14 Will be handled by AE.
10.25 Reviewer invited
10.31 Reviewer invited status changed once (Associate editor sent out another invitation)
11.1 Under review (Found out this morning that one reviewer has accepted)
12.3 This reviewer still has not submitted a report.
2024
5.7 DIP after 7 months of 2nd review
5.8 Minor revisions
5.14 Minor revisions have been returned
5.23 Accept~

(0) 讚！ | Hi_

23/Nov/2023 Submitted
26/Nov/2023 Under Review
28/Dec/2023 Major Revision (3 major 1 accept)
01/Mar/2024 Resubmit
06/Mar/2024 Under Review
04/Apr/2024 Minor Revision (2 accept, 1 accept with minor changes)
05/Apr/2024 Resubmitted
11/Apr/2024 Under Review
28/Apr/2024 Accept

This submission process was quite miraculous. I invited 5 reviewers when submitting, and amazingly all of them accepted the invitation. Eventually, I received feedback from 4 reviewers. One of them seemed to be almost certainly an expert in this field in Europe (relatively niche, and I've read most of the well-known articles in the industry). The questions raised were sharp and hit the key points, requiring a lot of effort to revise. I responded with a 20-page response to them, but this expert didn't even look at my paper during the second review... Could it be that Europe is still on vacation? The remaining reviewers thought our work was good, and after another round of minor revisions, we obtained 3 acceptances

(0) 讚！ | yy_nash13

Submitted on March 5th, results will be replied in 1 month.
We found 3 reviewers on WeChat. However, the editor only forwarded comments from 2 reviewers. One reviewer gave a positive evaluation, while the other hinted at rejection. The editor suggested resubmitting elsewhere

(1) 讚！ | Bear547

Submitted to remote sensing on 28th October 2023, desk rejected on 31st October 2023

(0) 讚！ | ddssew