Oct 31 2023, Submitted to Journal
Nov 01 2023, With Editor
Nov 02 2023, Under Review
Feb 14 2024, Major Revision
Mar 06 2024, Revision submitted
May 14 2024, Accepted
The review process was quick, with the first review taking three months, the second review taking two months, and the overall process lasting six months, which is an acceptable speed. Both reviewers provided very professional feedback, which was helpful in improving the quality of the article.
The article was originally submitted to a top-tier journal, but was accepted in a lower tier; I'm not sure how the Chinese Academy of Sciences determines this, but it's interesting

(0) 讚！ | Hly136

Laughing to death. PO can be divided into three districts, it's not as good as the domestic JOL. The Chinese Academy of Sciences is awesome

(0) 讚！ | 怒砸键盘的NEET姬

Sep 01, 2023: Initial Date Submitted
Dec 14, 2023: 2 Minor Revisions (3 weeks)
Dec 28, 2023: Chinese Academy of Sciences Division Three ......
Partitioning is not necessary

(121) 讚！ | ZLWu

2022.10.3 Submission
2022.12.18 Major revision (20-day modification)
2023.1.08 Minor revision
2023.2.11 Minor revision
2023.3.1 Acceptance
2023.3.4 Proofreading and online publication
The peer review efficiency of the journal is still very high, and the questions raised by the reviewers are very professional. During the first review, the editor invited two expert reviewers, and during the second review, an additional expert was added. As a well-established journal in the field of marine science, PO has a good reputation in the industry, although it has a lower level of recognition due to its low publication volume. Fortunately, it has always been classified as a first-tier journal by the Chinese Academy of Sciences. I hope that PO Journal will continue to improve, and I will submit suitable manuscripts in the future.

(0) 讚！ | 松岭路北

As an old magazine in the field of oceanography research (publishing about 150 articles per year), although PO has consistently had a high ranking and impact factor, its popularity in China has always been weaker than JGR-Oceans (publishing about 600 articles per year), especially in the field of physical oceanography. Journals with long submission cycles, strict review processes, and low publication volumes like this are indeed not very popular. Similar journals include Journal of Physical Oceanography (publishing about 150 articles per year) and Ocean Modelling (publishing about 90 articles per year), which are more theoretical and have a smaller audience. I hope these well-established journals can continue to improve!

(6) 讚！ | hifidreamer

The journal is of good quality and has high requirements for manuscripts. It’s very fast from receiving to publishing the paper.

(1) 讚！ | 匿名

Journal Homepage URL: http://www.elsevier.com/wps/find ... ription#description

(0) 讚！ | 匿名