I chose biological control. The editor is very efficient.

(0) 讚！ | lulu拉拉的sci

May I ask what kind of article you submitted? Is the editor responsive?

(0) 讚！ | anxuanxian

Finally, it's my turn to share. This journal is from the American Phytopathological Society. Although the impact factor is low, the quality is really good. The reviewers have strict requirements for the experimental design and even stricter language control. I tried using the Elsevier website for language polishing twice, but it didn't work, so the editor personally made the modifications. Very nice.

Submission timeline:
April 21, 2021: Submitted
May 20, 2021: Rejected, revised and resubmitted (added genomic data and reanalyzed the overall experimental data using bioinformatics)
December 1, 2021: Submitted
February 14, 2022: Major revision
April 21, 2022: Revised
May 24, 2022: Accepted with minor revisions
June 1, 2022: Revised
June 5, 2022: Accepted with minor revisions
June 7, 2022: Revised
July 14, 2022: Accepted

(11) 讚！ | lulu拉拉的sci

Submitted on March 14th, about three weeks later, the editor was reviewing the manuscript. After more than one week, the first trial returned on April 12th, suggesting an overhaul.I have been dragging on for a long time, submitted on June 6th, and so on, etc., received the acceptance message on June 29th and needed minor repairs...It is not easy to send a paper. Reviewer said that the paper is concise after the overhaul, so the overhaul must be taken seriously!

(0) 讚！ | J.J.

Submitted on March 14th, about three weeks later, the editor reviewed the manuscript. Note: all revision requests need to be taken very seriously or your paper won’t be accepted.

(0) 讚！ | J.J.

The review is very strict, the rigor of the experimental design is very high, and the details are very serious.

(0) 讚！ | 植病人

3Submission in mid-March, overhaul in mid-May, return at the end of June, minor repair in early August, accepted in early September.The review requirements are relatively high and attention to detail.

(1) 讚！ | Anonymous