The comments from the PRE reviewers are extremely professional, rigorous, and constructive! It is truly a top authority journal in the field of nonlinear physics and statistical physics, with high recognition and worth investing in! If luck is a little better, there are already 3 papers now! Unfortunately, I encountered a very, very unpleasant reviewer in the middle, but it is still very lucky to be able to publish 2 papers! I hope the journal will continue to improve!

(1) 讚！ | Dynamics

Submitted on March 26
Revised on July 2
Re-revised on August 6
Accepted on August 23
Published on October 8

(1) 讚！ | shujunyy123

After being rejected, Tata Kai succeeded in the second submission with minor revisions and was accepted directly

(2) 讚！ | lydasein

A very good journal in the field of nonlinear physics, unfortunately classified as a third-tier journal by the Chinese Academy of Sciences. After minor revisions, the paper was accepted, taking exactly 4 months from submission to publication

(2) 讚！ | yang255125

If the article is highly innovative, it is recommended to submit to PRE. Two articles have been published, and the summary is that the acceptance of innovation by reviewers and editors is very high. A series of journals highly recognized in the physics community

(18) 讚！ | Yutyyy

My dream magazine, post a few waistcoats and they will be stiff

(92) 讚！ | 比鲁斯

Undoubtedly a great journal of nonlinear physics! There are many high-quality works in it, and L is the one

(34) 讚！ | 纳维

23 Feb 2023  submit
27 Feb 2023  under review
17 May 2023  review completed, major revision. 
15 Jun 2023  responses submitted.
10 Jul 2023  review completed.
14 Jul 2023  accepted.

Translation:
23rd February 2023  - Submitted
27th February 2023  - Under review
17th May 2023  - Review completed, major revision. 
15th June 2023  - Responses submitted.
10th July 2023  - Review completed.
14th July 2023  - Accepted.

(1) 讚！ | 狂飙_NDyn

The industry influence is still significant. It was submitted on March 21 and accepted on June 20. It emphasizes explanations based on physical mechanisms and the questions asked by the reviewers are relevant. It is a good journal.

(0) 讚！ | 一块积木

What is the final result of the revised and resubmitted?

(0) 讚！ | dingdang001

The JCR of WoB is divided into tiers every 25%, resembling a bucket shape. On the other hand, the JCR of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) is divided in a pyramid shape, with a smaller proportion for the first tier, fewer for the second tier, and an increase in the number of journals in the third and fourth tiers.

(0) 讚！ | EchoGee

The journal has good quality, high recognition within the industry, and the reviewers are extremely professional. The questions they raise are sharp and to the point. The editors are also responsible and there is a noticeable improvement in the quality of the articles from submission to acceptance.

(6) 讚！ | YDDDu

May I ask which are the top ten main journals?

(0) 讚！ | 斯是陋室焉

Nonlinear, chaotic, fluid, and plasma physics are absolutely excellent journals in the field, and publishing several papers in them definitely represents the level of this field!

(67) 讚！ | 似水流年

I have submitted it twice but it hasn't been reviewed. It is considered a top-level journal in the field of mathematical physics and fluid plasma physics. The requirements for physical mechanisms and models are very high, making it difficult to get accepted. By publishing 2-3 papers in fluid physics, one would be eligible to apply for prestigious projects.

(87) 讚！ | 肖敏芳

two articles, are two reviewers.The first post was acceptd after the overhaul.The second post was directly acceptd after the minor repair (submission to the recruitment, less than three months).PRE is a top journal in the field of nonlinear physics and fluid physics, and the quality of the papers is very high.The web of science (JCR) fluid journals total 31, and the PRE ranked 10th and 2nd.In the field of mathematical physics, there are 6th and 1st districts in 55 journals.I don't know what to do, the Chinese Academy of Sciences has divided the PRE into the three districts.

(0) 讚！ | CE2018

Reviewing speed is faster, three reviewers, mainly researching stochastic resonance, very good journals in the nonlinear field.

(0) 讚！ | Joy

After a foreigner, I hope to submitted early in the morning

(0) 讚！ | stai

The top journal of nonlinear physics, second only to the top journal PRL, but also a very high-end journal.

(1) 讚！ | 庞加莱

PRE Since becoming the so-called three districts, it seems that quality has started to increase again...Ha ha

(2) 讚！ | 匿名

There were a few articles in the past. At that time, the boss’s name was hung behind, and my heart was quite solid.After working, I changed my direction. I was very happy when I got my head from the beginning.In fact, at the beginning of the prl, I tried it, and I didn’t report much hope in my heart.After reviewing the comments, it is not completely unsatisfactory, but it is not firm, and it is afraid of being assessed and applying for funds. I don’t want to spend time trying to end up trying to hang, and decisively switch to pre.It turns out that the two reviewers of prl have no news, and the other is very satisfied with the revised manuscript. The editor also found the third reviewer, but this brother did not raise the substantive opinions, so he agreed to prl.Two people's opinions.In my heart, I said that I have changed it. You are still interested.

(0) 讚！ | 匿名

Physical Review E, Journal of Fluid Mechanics, Journal of Computational Physics is a famous authority in fluid mechanics and computational fluid dynamics.Journal.

(0) 讚！ | 匿名

Do non-linear physics and statistics, no PRE articles, really can not be qualified.In the above article, in addition to new ideas, there must be a theoretical depth.

(2) 讚！ | 匿名

I think that for linear physics and soft matter physics, this PRE is still a very good journal; the editor is very dedicated, and the reviewer's opinion is also very pertinent. I published in the journal last year. This journal is also the top journal in soft matter and nonlinear physics. The IF is not that high, though.

(3) 讚！ | 匿名

can also

(0) 讚！ | 匿名