Not recommended for submission, the editor is extremely lazy and the review process is very long. On average, an invitation for review is sent every two months, and it can take up to six months for a review invitation to be extended. No one accepts the invitations each time. Minor revisions are required for resubmission, and the editor lacks any judgment ability. I admit defeat this time, if I am rejected, I will immediately submit elsewhere, it's too terrifying.

It's already 24-5-29 and there is still no information on invited reviewers. Sending a reminder email resulted in a generic response from the journal system. The editor is Tunna Baruah, an incompetent Indian

(0) 讚！ | CyCy!!!

It's been 5 months and not a single reviewer has accepted. I'm so frustrated. I only invited 6 in total

(0) 讚！ | 2023mjl

Hello friend, I wanted to ask who the reviewer is that Xiaoni picked

(0) 讚！ | 八爪鱼。

Received 19 September 2023, Revised 7 December 2023, Accepted 17 December 2023, Available online 19 December 2023.
Unfortunately, after being rejected by JMMM, it was resubmitted to Physic B Condensed Matter. Despite some setbacks, it was accepted in the end

(0) 讚！ | 王珂

submitted to journal 2023.10.18
with editor 2023.10.19
under review 2023.10.22
minor revise 2023.11.20
recision submitted to journal 2023.12.01
with editor 2023.12.02
under review 2023.12.06
accept 2023.12.17

审稿人是Hong Zhang Editor，非常的负责和专业。一审不到一个月，非常快。两个审稿人一个接受，一个给了四条意见的小修，给了20天修改。基本上没啥大问题，十天就修改完毕，返给编辑了。本以为会直接小修之后accept，结果编辑大大给送审了，真的非常负责。二审，只送了一个审稿人，审稿人也没啥意见，建议直接接受。
总的来说，PHYSICA B-CONDENSED MATTER 速度很快，之前投PRB三个月才给一审结果，搞得来来回回耽误了四个月，眼看明年要毕业了，急死个人。建议急着发paper的同学可以试试这个期刊，而且今年中科院分区和IF也上涨了，性价比挺高的

(0) 讚！ | 树树树

Hello, passing friend, how much should the plagiarism rate of this journal be lowered?

(0) 讚！ | 助教

This journal assigned the editor quite early. The reviewer assignment was also quick. One reviewer accepted the invite and completed the assignment in 21 days. The editor was not able to assign new reviewer for 2 full months. Upon contacting the journal on a number of occasions, there was no response from the editor. At last we had to withdraw it after 3 months upon non-response. Bad experience. Not suggested for submission.

(0) 讚！ | NavPhy

Yes, accepted after modification. DFT pure calculation.

(2) 讚！ | dybala

The submission was made in August 2022. It took three months to find reviewers for the first review, and then another three months for the review process. After the first review, there were two reviewers, one suggesting minor revisions and one disagreeing with acceptance. Finally, the editor probably requested some modifications before accepting the paper (thanks to the editor). The second round of revisions took about a month before acceptance in March 2023. Overall, the initial stages were very slow and particularly agonizing.

(0) 讚！ | 夏风如歌

I made two revisions, but my submission was still rejected. I am speechless. None of the three reviewers understood it and made random comments.

(0) 讚！ | zhou,weei

The submission and response process took a total of five weeks. The processing speed of the journal this year is really fast. The impact factor has also increased significantly. I personally think it will stabilize in the third quartile in the future. It's still a good opportunity since it just went up. However, there is still a need for some minor innovations. Overall, it is worth submitting to.

(28) 讚！ | 最强大脑中国好声音

From submission to acceptance, it took nearly 18 months!!!!!!!!! It doesn't matter whether this is a special case or not. Such a journal should be closed. It doesn't have the basic ability of processing. Could this be a scientific journal? And the editors basically ignore everything.

(1) 讚！ | ZLPD

Does Physica B: Condensed Matter publish review articles? I have a review, discussing the new method to study phase transition, especially the application, but it is very likely that the article doesn’t cite the article published in Physica B: Condensed Matter. Is it possible not to be accepted? I wonder if the editor of this journal is generous?

(0) 讚！ | 村中城

As long as there is a little innovation, this journal is still happy to receive various physics and materials articles. A small part of the article I submitted is about preparation of thin films by magnetron sputtering, and the other parts is about the theoretical calculation of the Miedema model. 7.1, submission; 7.14, comments from one reviewer were raised (submitted to the journal on August 30). I was arranged to submit the revised manuscript in about half a month, so on. It was not accepted until September 11; it hasn’t been published. However, it will be published in these days. I can’t wait to share with you first.

(1) 讚！ | Dragon551

11.19 Submission, 12.07 notice minor repair, 12.14 repair, accepted that night, 12.18online

(2) 讚！ | qingfeng11

6 on the 12th,17th with editor.July 1st (Return to the review draft on the evening of the founding of the Party Day, minor repair).Return to the journal on July 10.Accepted on July 11th, the same day online check.On July 14th, the volume and page number are given..It lasted for a month.The reviewer is a teacher at a university in China, a big cow in this field.The so-called "extreme challenge, this is life" refueling

(5) 讚！ | 1505011688@qq.com

6 on the 12th,17th with editor.July 1st (Return to the review draft on the evening of the founding of the Party Day, minor repair).Return to the journal on July 10.Accepted on July 11th, the same day online check.On July 14th, the volume and page number are given..It lasted for a month.The reviewer is a teacher at a university in China, a big cow in this field.The so-called "extreme challenge, this is the life" refueling

(1) 讚！ | 1505011688@qq.com

6 on the 12th,17th with editor.July 1st (Return to the review draft on the night of the Army Day, minor repair).Return to the journal on July 10.Accepted on July 11th, the same day online check.On July 14th, the volume and page number are given..It lasted for a month.The reviewer is a teacher at a university in China, a big cow in this field.The so-called "extreme challenge, this is the life" refueling

(6) 讚！ | 1505011688@qq.com

6February 12 contribution,17th with editor.July 1st (Return to the review draft on the night of the Army Day, minor repair).Return to the journal on July 10.Accepted on July 11th, the same day online check.On July 14th, the volume and page number are given..It lasted for a month.The reviewer is a teacher at a university in China, a big cow in this field.The so-called "extreme challenge, this is life" refueling

(2) 讚！ | 1505011688@qq.com

The journal is still good, the editor is also very responsible, the manuscript is processed very quickly, and the result is within one month. I hope the journal will be better and better!

(2) 讚！ | VANCLE

The journal is still good, the editor is also very responsible, the manuscript is processed very quickly, and the result is within one month. I hope the journal will be better and better!

(0) 讚！ | VANCLE

The article that was submitted in December 2015 is still under review!More than 6 months!!!Life and death are not clear!!!The future!!!

(0) 讚！ | Dy2O3

From submission to recruitment, it took a year and two months to finally receive it, I am so happy!The editors and reviewers are very serious and have given me a lot of pertinent opinions.This journal has been rising all the time, and it will be better and better!

(1) 讚！ | 匿名

I don’t say anything, wait a minute, look for the reviewer, I know who it is, wait a minute, I want to see what the reviewers of this journal want to do?

(0) 讚！ | 匿名

Is PHYSICA B a journal for several districts?Some schools are divided into districts, and some schools use graduation factors to determine graduation requirements.

(0) 讚！ | 匿名