Three reviewers, demanding high innovation

生產	13 November 2024
最終前期審查	13 November 2024
複製修訂	12 November 2024
最終前期審查	11 November 2024
重新審查決定	11 November 2024
評價重新審查者	11 November 2024
重新審查	19 October 2024
最終稿件決定	18 October 2024
作者修訂	14 October 2024
前期審查	13 October 2024
初稿件決定	13 October 2024
評價審稿人	13 October 2024
同行評審	4 October 2024
分配編輯	2 October 2024
質量檢查	2 October 2024
提交稿件	1 October 2024

(0) 讚！ | 飞扬321

Hello, do you need page charges for this journal?

(0) 讚！ | muyu2023

We only accept letters, please do not submit long articles.

(0) 讚！ | Metalcry

Why is there only the option for "letter" in the submission system, and not "article"?

(0) 讚！ | 桥小茄

Hello everyone, the images in the latex compressed file I submitted for Provisional Acceptance are still in jpg format. It's already the second day of Final Manuscript Decision, please, is there still hope for me?

(0) 讚！ | zengjinghui

No problem.

(0) 讚！ | 桥小茄

Final Preproduction Review 13 September 2024 16 September 2024 Production
Final Manuscript Decision 13 September 2024 13 September 2024 Manuscript Accepted
Author Revision 09 September 2024 13 September 2024 Author Revisions Complete
Preproduction Review 08 September 2024 09 September 2024 Author Revision
First Manuscript Decision 08 September 2024 08 September 2024 Provisional Acceptance
Rate Reviewers 08 September 2024 08 September 2024 Reviewer Rating Completed
Peer Review 15 August 2024 08 September 2024 Peer Review Complete

(0) 讚！ | 小北℃

Peer Review 30 August 2024
Assign Editor 29 August 2024 30 August 2024 Editor Assigned
Quality Check 26 August 2024 29 August 2024 Quality Check Passed
Submit Manuscript 26 August 2024 26 August 2024 Submission Complete
Waiting, probably three to four weeks? Hoping for a positive outcome.

(0) 讚！ | ccshangan

Final Manuscript Decision	August 16, 2024	Manuscript Accepted
Author Revision	August 14, 2024	Author Revisions Complete
Preproduction Review	August 12, 2024	Author Revision
First Manuscript Decision	August 12, 2024	Provisional Acceptance
Rate Reviewers	August 12, 2024	Reviewer Rating Completed
Peer Review	July 25, 2024	August 12, 2024	Peer Review Complete
Assign Editor	July 25, 2024	Editor Assigned
Quality Check	July 25, 2024	Quality Check Passed
Submit Manuscript	July 23, 2024	Submission Complete

(0) 讚！ | Hammerdai

May I ask how long it takes for you to provide the final decision? It has been two days since the minor revisions were submitted and we are feeling anxious.

(0) 讚！ | 北方搬砖人

It is strictly limited to four pages.

(0) 讚！ | zengjinghui

Both reviewers have recommended major revisions. According to the guidelines of Optics Letters, a manuscript must receive two clearly positive reviews in order to undergo major revisions. Therefore, I regret to inform you that your manuscript cannot be accepted for publication in Optics Letters. However, I am open to considering a revised version of your manuscript if you choose to resubmit it. The revised manuscript will undergo another review process by the same reviewers.

(1) 讚！ | Samaras Wang

Starting from March, I have had three consecutive simulation articles accepted. I had heard that the initial review would screen out some articles, but I did not encounter this situation. Perhaps it exists with some editors. These three articles were handled by two different editors. The first article took over a month for the initial review, underwent major revisions, and was accepted within a week after the revisions. The next two articles were also resubmitted after major revisions. After resubmission, they were reviewed by the original reviewers, and as long as I responded seriously, I did not encounter any difficult issues. One of the articles was processed very quickly, being reviewed and accepted within a week of submission. After resubmission, the reviewer's responses were also very quick, so the entire process from idea to publication (not just acceptance) took only two and a half months. Overall, the speed of article processing depends on the editor. In comparison to other journals, the speed I experienced was already very fast. The slowest response I received was just over a month. Overall, my experience with submitting articles was very positive. As long as the article is innovative in engineering or science, it is worth a try. The editors are fair and base their decisions solely on the review results. If both reviews are positive, minor revisions will be required. If one review is positive and the other suggests major revisions, you will be asked to revise and resubmit, but as long as you make the necessary revisions, your article will eventually be accepted. Good luck to everyone.

(1) 讚！ | Samaras Wang

The final decision has been made and is pending. It has been 10 days and the outcome is still unknown.

(0) 讚！ | 你uncle的

Hello, my research area is also in optical imaging combined with deep learning. However, my submissions have not been passing the quality review in the submission system. I would like to ask if there is a page limit for submissions in the OL system.

(0) 讚！ | Alian666

Hello, is there a limit to the number of pages for this submission?

(0) 讚！ | Alian666

Optics Letters Peer Review Main Peer Review Complete No Reviews
What does this status mean? Will it go directly to First Manuscript Decision?

(0) 讚！ | 桥小茄

Still looking for an editor.

(1) 讚！ | 乐橙清

Has the review comments come back at this stage?

(0) 讚！ | 乐橙清

Reviewer 1 Expired (June 1, 2024)
Reviewer 2 Agree (May 17, 2024) Complete (May 17, 2024)
Reviewer 3 Too Busy (May 23, 2024)
Reviewer 4 Expired (June 18, 2024)
Reviewer 5 Too Busy (June 24, 2024)
Reviewer 6 Too Busy (June 22, 2024)

(0) 讚！ | 乐橙清

Rate Reviewers19 June 2024	19 June 2024	Reviewer Rating Completed
Peer Review25 May 2024	19 June 2024	Peer Review Complete
Assign Editor23 May 2024	25 May 2024	Editor Assigned
Peer Review16 May 2024	23 May 2024	peerreviewMain_EditorDeclined
Assign Editor15 May 2024	16 May 2024	Editor Assigned
Quality Check15 May 2024	15 May 2024	Quality Check Passed
Submit Manuscript14 May 2024	15 May 2024	Submission Complete

(0) 讚！ | 向日葵好吃

Directly using the Overleaf template, but raised formatting issues in the Pre-Production Review section. May I ask what the spacing format is for images and formulas?

(0) 讚！ | 向日葵好吃

Hello, may I ask if you know what peerreviewMain_EditorDeclined refers to?

(0) 讚！ | lilili0613

Assign Editor 22 June 2024
Peer Review 21 June 2024 - 22 June 2024 peerreviewMain_EditorDeclined
Assign Editor 21 June 2024 - 21 June 2024 Editor Assigned
Quality Check 21 June 2024 - 21 June 2024 Quality Check Passed
Resubmit Manuscript 20 June 2024 - 21 June 2024 Resubmission Complete
Quality Check 20 June 2024 - 20 June 2024 Quality Check Failed
Submit Manuscript 20 June 2024 - 20 June 2024 Submission Complete

(0) 讚！ | lilili0613

Okay, thank you for your reply.

(0) 讚！ | zengjinghui