One of the reviewers clearly provided a review generated by AI (confirmed by AIGC detection). Can we address this issue in the editor's rebuttal?

(0) 讚！ | wzaxl123

I haven't submitted it for review for a month.

(0) 讚！ | yeye809

Submitted to journal on 15th March 2025. With editor on 17th March 2025. It's been a week and still not sent for review, so frustrating.

(0) 讚！ | xuaner1111

2024.08.23 Submitted to journal
2024.08.25 With editor
2024.08.26 Under Review
2024.12.31 Under Review
2025.01.11 RRC
2025.01.15 revised
2025.01.29 With editor
2025.02.06-2025.03.16 Under Review
2025.03.16 RRC
2025.03.17 DIP
2025.03.17 Minor Revision
2025.03.21 With Editor
2025.03.23 Accept

It took 7 months, during which no emails were sent to urge the editor. The status changed on the mini-program for the first review, inviting 19 reviewers but only two agreed to review. The second review took two months, and it was later discovered that a third reviewer had been invited. The editor and reviewers were very responsible and provided many constructive suggestions. Wishing OLE continued success and hoping that everyone's submissions will be accepted soon.

(0) 讚！ | 那咋办嘛

May I ask if after the journal revision, will a new track link be provided? Is the link supposed to look like this: https://track.authorhub.elsevier.com/?uuid=XXXX?

(0) 讚！ | chen

25.3.3 sub
25.3.4 with editor

(0) 讚！ | 遇然

25.3.3 sub
25.3.4 we

(0) 讚！ | 遇然

Is it possible for this journal to drop to the third quartile?

(0) 讚！ | 虾米

May I ask how long it takes for the DIP to get results?

(0) 讚！ | 如幻。

How long does it take for DIP to have results?

(0) 讚！ | 如幻。

May I ask if you were rejected later?

(0) 讚！ | yutongguo0808

Required Reviews Completed 03/08/2025. 3 reviewers agreed, and 2 reviewers completed their reviews.

(0) 讚！ | ljw

May I ask how is the result? How long does the dip take?

(0) 讚！ | ljw

Submitted to Journal 02/18/2025
With Editor 02/18/2025
With Editor 02/20/2025
Under Review 02/21/2025 7-1-0
Under Review 03/01/2025 7-1-0
Under Review 03/03/2025 14-3-0

(0) 讚！ | ljw

How are you?

(0) 讚！ | Messijames

Submission on December 24, 2024
Major revision on January 24, 2025
Revised on February 10, 2025
Under review on February 16, 2025
Revised and resubmitted on March 4, 2025

(0) 讚！ | 6471

Submission on December 10, 2023
First-round review results on January 22, 2024 (major revisions)
Revised manuscript returned on February 8, 2024
Accepted on February 28, 2024

(0) 讚！ | 仪科学徒

I have not received any news since submitting the article on February 20, 2025.

(0) 讚！ | yeye809

Delivered on October 22, 2024
Received on February 19, 2025
Underwent a major revision in between, a very pleasant submission experience. I hope the journal continues to improve.

(0) 讚！ | zxu_fly

01/15/2025 Submitted
01/18/2025 Under review (2/3/8)
02/08/2025 Decision in Process
02/10/2025 Major revision

Submitted on 01/15/2025
Under review on 01/18/2025 with 2 out of 8 reviewers responding
Decision in Process on 02/08/2025
Major revision requested on 02/10/2025

The paper was reviewed within three days and a decision was made within two days. The editorial team worked efficiently with an average review time of 2-3 weeks, reaching out to eight reviewers with three agreeing to review. In the end, feedback was received from two reviewers.

A two-week period was given for major revisions. Both reviewers provided positive feedback, with one providing only four suggestions and the other recommending acceptance with minor revisions. It is unclear why a major revision was ultimately requested.

(0) 讚！ | Panpan1995

In general, this situation arises when there are conflicting review opinions. The editor is unable to make a decision, so another reviewer is added.

(0) 讚！ | xnnnsr

Submission on 12.13.2024
We on 12.14.2024
Under review on 12.15.2024
Required reviews completed on 1.3.2024 (two reviews completed)
Under review again on 1.12.2024, is it rejected? Why did it go from required reviews completed to under review again?

(0) 讚！ | hhewang

The submission was made in early October, and it was accepted for publication in early January 2025. The response time was quite fast.

(0) 讚！ | jsdtqk

The journal review process is very efficient, with the longest time being spent "with editor". Here is a timeline for reference:
2024.10.23 submitted to journal
2024.10.25 with editor
2024.11.22 Under review
2024.12.08 Under review
2024.12.19 Decision in process
2024.12.23 Minor Revise
2024.12.29 With Editor (returned manuscript)
2024.1.1 Accept

(0) 讚！ | Abbylove

Submission on November 18, 2024
Two reviewers completed the review on December 16, 2024
Decision in Principle on December 20, 2024
(Continuously updated, wishing everyone good luck with acceptance!)

(0) 讚！ | HNU-YWB