Manuscript Accepted	2024-05-16
Decision Made	2024-05-16
Decision Pending	2024-05-15
Manuscript Decision Made	2024-05-15
Under Review	2024-05-10
Under Consideration	2024-05-06
Waiting for Revision	2024-03-28
Decision Made	2024-03-28
Decision Pending	2024-03-27
Manuscript Revise and Re-Review	2024-03-27
Under Review	2024-02-16
Under Consideration	2024-01-24
2024-01-15
Submission	2024-01-12

(0) 讚！ | 静逸轩

The review was very professional and detailed, pointing out errors in the reference years and page numbers. Thank you to the reviewers and editors for their evaluation

(0) 讚！ | 静逸轩

Do all authors need to register and confirm for submission?

(0) 讚！ | 李云哲

How long does it usually take to receive the galley proof email after acceptance? Will every author receive it?

(0) 讚！ | 落0623

2023-12-26 Submission
2024-01-03 Under Consideration
2024-02-23 Under Review
2024-03-17 Manuscript Revise and Re-Review
2024-03-19 Decision Made
2024-04-04 Submission
2024-04-04 Under Consideration
2024-04-19 Under Review
2024-05-03 Manuscript Accepted

(0) 讚！ | 落0623

Accepted before graduation, very nice!

(0) 讚！ | 落0623

Under Consideration 2023-12-17
Waiting for Revision 2023-12-09
Decision Made 2023-12-09
Decision Pending 2023-12-08
Manuscript Revise and Re-Review 2023-12-08
Under Review 2023-08-22
Under Consideration 2023-07-27
Submission 2023-07-25

(0) 讚！ | 小杨爱酷

Manuscript Accepted 2024-03-07
Decision Made 2024-03-07
Decision Pending 2024-03-07
Manuscript Decision Made 2024-03-07
Under Review 2024-03-04
Under Consideration 2024-02-27
Submission 2024-02-27
Under Consideration 2024-02-27
Waiting for Revision 2024-02-26
Decision Made 2024-02-26
Decision Pending 2024-02-25
Manuscript Revise Only 2024-02-25
Under Review 2024-01-03
Under Consideration 2023-12-17
Submission 2023-12-17

(0) 讚！ | 小杨爱酷

Approaching graduation, ready to happily graduate

(0) 讚！ | 小杨爱酷

Is it likely to be rejected soon if there is no revise after my paper is under review?

(0) 讚！ | GggZZ

Boss, the status of my submission shows "pending decision" directly, without "manuscript revise only". Does this mean it has been sent directly?

(0) 讚！ | GggZZ

Manuscript Sent to Production 2023-08-05
Manuscript Accepted 2023-08-03
Decision Made 2023-08-03
Decision Pending 2023-08-03
Manuscript Decision Made 2023-08-03
Under Review 2023-08-02
Under Consideration 2023-07-29
Submission 2023-07-18
Under Consideration 2023-07-29
Waiting for Revision 2023-07-18
Decision Made 2023-07-18
Decision Pending 2023-07-17
Manuscript Revise Only 2023-07-17
Under Review 2023-03-14
Under Consideration 2023-02-13
Submission 2023-02-12

(0) 讚！ | 火法冶金张师傅

Manuscript Accepted - 2023-02-17
Decision Made - 2023-02-17
Decision Pending - 2023-02-10
Manuscript Decision Made - 2023-02-10
Under Review - 2023-02-06
Under Consideration - 2023-01-31
Waiting for Revision - 2023-01-12
Decision Made - 2023-01-12
Decision Pending - 2023-01-08
Manuscript Revise Only - 2023-01-08
Under Review - 2022-10-10
Under Consideration - 2022-09-21
Submission - 2022-09-20
The process is a bit slow, but the reviewers are still professional.

(0) 讚！ | CSURanLing

Hired after major revisions, thank you, grateful! 
Manuscript Sent to Production	2022-08-20
Manuscript Accepted	2022-08-19
Decision Made	2022-08-19
Decision Pending	2022-08-19
Manuscript Decision Made	2022-08-19
Under Review	2022-08-19
Under Consideration	2022-08-18
Waiting for Revision	2022-08-18
Decision Made	2022-08-18
Decision Pending	2022-08-05
Manuscript Decision Made	2022-08-05
Under Review	2022-08-03
Manuscript Revise and Re-Review	2022-07-15
Under Review	2022-07-05
Under Consideration	2022-06-28
Submission	2022-06-16

(0) 讚！ | 凌风

Manuscript Accepted 2022-05-19
Decision Made 2022-05-19
Decision Pending 2022-05-13
Manuscript Decision Made 2022-05-13
Under Review 2022-05-12
Under Consideration 2022-05-10
Waiting for Revision 2022-05-05
Decision Made 2022-05-05
Decision Pending 2022-04-29
Manuscript Revise Only 2022-04-29
Under Review 2022-04-01
Under Consideration 2022-03-21
Submission 2022-03-17
The time for minor revisions is still acceptable, and the acceptance will be quick after the revisions are completed.

(2) 讚！ | 火法冶金张师傅

International top journals in the field of pyrometallurgy, with a low impact factor but high influence within the field. Personally, I have published four papers in these journals, but it doesn't provide much advantage when it comes to finding a job in the field of metallurgical engineering.

(34) 讚！ | kaiye

With just two articles, you can get a teaching job, at which school?

(0) 讚！ | kaiye

Manuscript Sent to Production 2022-01-27
Manuscript Accepted 2022-01-24
Decision Made 2022-01-24
Decision Pending 2022-01-23
Manuscript Decision Made 2022-01-23
Under Review 2021-12-14
Under Consideration 2021-11-28
Waiting for Revision 2021-11-09
Decision Made 2021-11-09
Decision Pending 2021-11-07
Manuscript Revise and Re-Review 2021-11-07
Under Review 2021-09-29
Under Consideration 2021-09-21
Submission 2021-08-31

As a student of metallurgical engineering, MMTB is worth submitting to. The journal has a high impact in the field of metallurgical engineering, and the reviewers have strong expertise, greatly improving the quality of the papers. However, the review process is very slow.

(2) 讚！ | Liuke0033

Manuscript Sent to Production 2022-02-24
Manuscript Accepted 2022-02-18
Decision Made 2022-02-18
Decision Pending 2022-02-15
Manuscript Decision Made 2022-02-15
Under Review 2022-02-14
Under Consideration 2022-02-13
Waiting for Revision 2022-02-09
Decision Made 2022-02-09
Decision Pending 2022-02-06
Manuscript Revise Only 2022-02-06
Under Review 2022-01-14
Under Consideration 2022-01-07
Submission 2021-12-21

(4) 讚！ | 悟小柳

After undergoing two revisions, the overall quality of the article has significantly improved. Before graduating with a PhD, I obtained my second MMTB, which further boosted my confidence and prepared me for a teaching career. I hope metallurgy students can publish more MMTBs to hone their skills, improve their level, and enhance their confidence.

(0) 讚！ | 一直前行探索

Manuscript Sent to Production 2021-06-30
Manuscript Accepted 2021-06-28
Decision Made 2021-06-28
Decision Pending 2021-06-28
Manuscript Decision Made 2021-06-28
Under Review 2021-06-11
Under Consideration 2021-06-03
Waiting for Revision 2021-05-04
Decision Made 2021-05-04
Decision Pending 2021-05-04
Manuscript Revise and Re-Review 2021-05-04
Under Review 2021-01-05
Under Consideration 2020-12-14
2020-11-25
Submission 2020-11-24

The only drawback is that the submission process is slightly long. I hope the journal can speed up the process for each stage.

(0) 讚！ | 一直前行探索

Decision Made 2021-02-17
Decision Pending 2021-02-12
Manuscript Decision Made 2021-02-12
Under Review 2020-12-21
Under Consideration 2020-12-10
2020-11-28
Submission 2020-11-28
One key reader, two reviewers, one positive opinion, one negative opinion, and one neutral opinion. The paper was rejected without the opportunity for revision, but no actual revision comments were provided. Several questions regarding industrial applications were raised, and the paper was subsequently submitted and accepted by the journal "Ironmaking and Steelmaking" within a month. However, it feels like there would have been a great chance for acceptance if given the opportunity for revision by MMTB. After all, it is a top-tier journal in the field of metallurgy, and I would recommend other students with good research to consider submitting there.

(0) 讚！ | 一直前行探索

Posted in September 2020, major revisions, rejected.
After filing a complaint in March 2021, the editor-in-chief requested resubmission, followed by major and minor revisions. Accepted on October 15th.

(2) 讚！ | 又中了

Manuscript Sent to Production	2021-06-10
Manuscript Accepted	2021-06-08
Decision Made	2021-06-08
Decision Pending	2021-06-03
Manuscript Decision Made	2021-06-03
Under Review	2021-06-03
Under Consideration	2021-05-26
Submission	2021-05-18
Decision Made	2021-05-12
Manuscript Revise Only	2021-05-11
Under Review	2021-03-10
Under Consideration	2021-03-01
Submission	2021-02-21

It takes about 4 months from submission to acceptance. This is generally the speed, but it's unfortunate that the journal has a high impact factor. Even though the impact factor is low, it's still worth submitting an article.

(21) 讚！ | 东哥哥

The editing efficiency is very high. One key reader, one reviewer, and accepted after minor revisions. It takes three months from submission to acceptance.

(0) 讚！ | hardcool