Is it possible to check the progress on the iThinkwell official account? You can view the status by the document number

(0) 讚！ | 大杯拿铁不加糖

2024-03-08 submission
2024-03-31 under review
It is still in this state now, I don't know why it is so slow, it has been more than two months, I want to send an email to urge it

(0) 讚！ | wu_liu_qi

May I please ask where to find the Word template for this journal? Thank you

(0) 讚！ | xsnjust

Is there no "with editor" option? I just submitted a continuous submission

(0) 讚！ | wx2

Is there no with editor for this journal?

(0) 讚！ | wx2

Can you please share your submission experience in detail, senior?

(0) 讚！ | 凯哥哥哥

Can papers that have been warned by medicine be submitted for publication? Also, isn't it required for the graduation thesis to have an impact factor of 3 or to be in the top 3 zones of the Chinese Academy of Sciences? Will it affect the graduation of a doctoral degree?

(0) 讚！ | hjb0

The second review is a bit slow, still under review after 35 days. Hopefully the reviewer can return faster

(0) 讚！ | 月面上挖井的傻狍子

2023.11.5 submit; 2024.01.19 Major revision; 2024.02.06 revision submit; 2024.02.08 Under Review. Still waiting for the results. We conducted engineering simulation experiments related to planetary science, and two reviewers provided very detailed comments, which greatly improved the manuscript. This article will also determine whether I can graduate with a PhD on time in June this year. I'm so nervous, I have to open the webpage every day to check the progress

(0) 讚！ | 月面上挖井的傻狍子

Accept and Appreciate Reviewer

(1) 讚！ | 哈库

On February 20th, acceptance, thank you to the editors and reviewers

(1) 讚！ | liusl

Two reviewers raised sharp questions, which were very professional and greatly helpful for improving the paper. They recommended major revisions and it took a long time to write responses. I hope the paper will be accepted. The journal is very professional, but the review process is a bit lengthy

(0) 讚！ | 哈库

Minor revisions on February 7th, revisions due on the 10th, still in the hands of the editor, hoping for approval

(1) 讚！ | liusl

2023-12-22 submission
2024-01-07 under review
2024-01-22 review complete
Transferred from Aerospace science and technology, the journal has been promoted to a major 2 zone. The process is fast, but the editors are peculiar. Only 3 reviewers were invited, and only 1 has accepted and provided feedback. Hopefully they will give a major revision

(0) 讚！ | liusl

2023-07-30 Submission
2023-08-03 Under Review
2023-10-30 Review Complete
2023-10-31 Minor Revision
2023-12-02 Under Review
2023-12-13 Accept
Found two reviewers, both junior researchers, their comments are very professional

(0) 讚！ | 快去写论文

2022.9.18 Submission
Within one week under review
2023.1.27 Minor revision
2023.2.3 Resubmission
2023.4.15 Accepted

(0) 讚！ | Shaw009

Aerospace engineering is a very prestigious journal, with a decent review speed and professional opinions from reviewers. The whole process from submission, revisions, to final acceptance took about two months. One of the reviewers provided over 30 comments, which we addressed one by one, supplemented with relevant experiments, and made corrections to the models. The reviewer's comments were very constructive and helped fill in our knowledge gaps and shortcomings, overall it was a good submission experience

(0) 讚！ | 快快毕业别延毕

20230222 submit - Submitted on February 22, 2023
20230310 major revision - Major revision on March 10, 2023
20230317 resubmit - Resubmitted on March 17, 2023
20230326 accept - Accepted on March 26, 2023

This time it was really quick, from submission to acceptance, including two rounds of review, it took only one month. I have submitted many times before, and personally, I think the editor usually selects two out of the five reviewers you recommend, so it is important to choose appropriate reviewers. This time, I can also deduce who the two scholars were who reviewed the manuscript.

(0) 讚！ | 山芋派

Did you remind the editor during your period? Someone couldn't find a reviewer for 7 months, but after reminding once, they got rejected.

(0) 讚！ | Zoey_Young

May I ask how did you follow up on the manuscript? I can't see who is the editor handling it.

(0) 讚！ | 小法吴

Excuse me, does this magazine have a Word template? Thank you!

(0) 讚！ | 换一个没人注册过的

2022.3.1 Submitted to Journal
2022.3.2 With Editor
2022.3.26 Under Review
2022.4.9 First reviewer's comments completed
2022.5.6 Sent letter to inquire about status
2022.5.7 Received reply, one reviewer has completed their review, while the other two reviewers have not responded yet. The third reviewer received the invitation to review, website updated.
2022.5.10 Website link updated, Required Reviews Completed
2022.5.21 Website link updated, Required Reviews Completed
2022.5.28 Website link updated, Decision in Process
2022.5.29 Minor revision
2022.6.24 Revised manuscript submitted
2022.6.25 With editor
2022.7.16 Decision in Process
2022.7.17 Accept

(3) 讚！ | 和尚庙住持