It has been 16 days since submission, hoping for a smooth process

(0) 讚！ | 必中必中

Looking forward to a good outcome

(0) 讚！ | 且寄流心

5/12 submission
5/13 designated associate editor Li-Jun Wan
At present, the results are unknown. Do any senior brothers and sisters who have submitted know the standards of Academician Wan? Personally, I feel that the work is very solid and comprehensive. I don't know if it will be sent for review

(0) 讚！ | miura

2024.02.01 Submitted
2024.02.11 Under Review
2024.03.19 Major revision (three minor revisions)
2024.04.12 Submitted
2024.04.16 Prepare to accept
2024.04.17 Submitted
2024.04.19 Accept

(1) 讚！ | yyan

Submitted on November 23rd, year 23.
Vice editor arranged for November 28th, year 23.
Rejected on January 4th, year 24, with minor revisions and one rejection.
Appealed to the editor-in-chief on January 5th, year 24.
Appeal was rejected on January 9th, year 24.
Appealed to the executive editor on January 17th, year 24.
Successfully appealed on January 19th, year 24, and was given a chance for resubmission.
Resubmitted on March 1st, year 24.
Vice editor arranged for March 5th, year 24.
Received feedback on April 9th, year 24, with a minor revision (very good feedback) and one direct acceptance, invited for cover.
Submitted on April 13th, year 24.
Prepared for acceptance on April 16th, year 24, adjusted the authorship format, and revised on the same day.
Accepted on April 17th, now waiting for the final proof

(3) 讚！ | ￥￥￥%%%@@@

Due to inconsistent reviews from the reviewers, a third reviewer was sought for reassessment, resulting in a delay of two and a half months for everyone's reference

(0) 讚！ | NiAz

Submitted on February 22nd, currently in peer review since March 6th, it has been three weeks. Please have mercy on the reviewers and release the manuscript!

(0) 讚！ | bigjar

1.15 Submission
1.18 Assigning Associate Editor
2.5 Under Review
I haven't received any feedback yet, and I feel very anxious. I don't know if I should check in with the Associate Editor

(4) 讚！ | NiAz

Did the editor refuse it? Will it be resubmitted after appeal?

(0) 讚！ | ￥￥￥%%%@@@

Submission at the end of January. One month for review. Two reviewers, one suggesting minor revisions, and the other recommending publication elsewhere. The feedback from the second reviewer was unreasonable. Directly refuted point by point. Submitted again after making minor revisions. There were also some text formatting corrections later. It was already online by mid-March

(2) 讚！ | woodrow33

What happened next?

(0) 讚！ | yyan

August 17, 2023 Submitted
August 25, 2023 Under review
September 16, 2023 Editorial decision – one rejection, one major revision, one minor revision, editor requested resubmission
January 5, 2024 Resubmitted
January 24, 2024 Second round of reviews – one major revision, one minor revision, editor requested major revision
February 23, 2024 Revised as per reviewer suggestions
March 6, 2024 Article accepted
March 14, 2024 Received review proof
March 17, 2024 Article goes online

(0) 讚！ | chemist Li

It may be very difficult to re-appeal after being rejected for a second time

(0) 讚！ | ￥￥￥%%%@@@

Excuse me, were you rejected at the second review or did you have to resubmit after a rejection?

(0) 讚！ | xiaopao

Admiring a genius

(2) 讚！ | lunwenfabiao

Just submitted my post, claiming a spot on the thread

(0) 讚！ | Byron Hu

09.08 Submission, assigned as associate editor on the same day
09.12 Under review
09.21 Received comments from reviewers, one minor revision and one rejection. The reason for rejection was absurd, suspected that they did not read the article carefully, argued on the same day
09.25 Editor agreed to major revision and invited for cover
11.08 Resubmission
11.23 Accepted in principle
12.12 Online
12.22 Cover accepted

(3) 讚！ | 白日梦蓝

My resubmission was rejected. Can I argue against it? One of the reviewers feels that my writing is inadequate. It took me six months to revise the article, only to be rejected with just one sentence

(0) 讚！ | 玉

December 1, 23: submit;
December 6, 23: assign to Prof. Hanadi Sleiman;
December 13, 23: In Peer Review;
January 8, 24: two minor revisions;
January 15, 24: submit revision;
February 7, 24: Format modification required.
February 9, 24: submit revision;
February 12, 24: Acceptance

(3) 讚！ | Aaron_Z

Submit the paper on September 14
Sent for review on September 19
Received initial review comments on October 11, one rejection, two major revisions; editor requested major revisions
Submit revised manuscript on October 25
Accepted on October 30
Very fast, high efficiency, can be accepted in about a month and a half, really like it

(15) 讚！ | magmagmag

Submitted to the system on August 9, 2023, arrived at the associate editor on August 14, received the review comments on October 2, with three reviewers, accepted after minor revisions by two, rejected after major revision by one, given one month for major revision by the editor, resubmitted on October 17, received an acceptance notification on October 24, but needed to adjust the size of a figure, completed the adjustments on October 25 and waiting for formal acceptance

(1) 讚！ | Waymaker

2023.6.29 JACS submission
7.5 assigned to editor
8.9 revision request, 2 minor revisions (5% top), 1 major revision
8.14 revised manuscript submission to JACS
9.6 pre-accepted
9.7 accepted
9.15 review proofs

(0) 讚！ | NanoAtom

How long does it take from accept to online?

(0) 讚！ | xjz980322

20230614 Submit to the journal
20230621 In peer review
20230706 Major revision (Three reviewers: 2 minor revisions, 1 major revision)
20230802 Resubmit to the journal
20230804 Preaccept (minor revision, format)
20230808 Accept

(24) 讚！ | Aspirin0810