I want to ask everyone, what are the format requirements for manuscripts when submitting? About 2 weeks after submission, the editorial department sent an email saying there were issues with the manuscript. The email read: "because the manuscript was not properly converted and the proof only contains the cover page. Each listed item must be addressed and modified in the manuscript. Can anyone tell me what went wrong?"

(0) 讚！ | 接accept!

I would like to ask everyone, what is the status of "under consideration"? The first submission had formatting issues, so the editor asked for a revision before resubmission. After the second submission, it still shows "under consideration." I searched on Baidu and some people said it means the reviewer is looking for a suitable editor, while others said it means the editor is considering whether to submit it for review

(2) 讚！ | Maddy

09.06 Submission
09.13 Returned, resubmitted
12.09 First round of reviews came back, one reviewer provided a lot of comments, one reviewer had no comments and suggested acceptance.
12.24 Returned
1.13 Re-reviewed, Reviewer 1 provided 2 more comments but suggested acceptance. Returned the same day.
Still Awaiting Admin Checklist till now.
The reviewers are very knowledgeable and raised many professional questions. The only downside is that it took a long time to find reviewers and the speed of editorial processing is average. However, I am grateful for the editors' and reviewers' affirmation of my work. Americeramics as an established journal has a good reputation, but I do not recommend impatient colleagues to submit articles

(1) 讚！ | hoda

Reading other people's comments, the review usually takes about a month to get the results. Just be patient and wait a little longer

(0) 讚！ | qq77qq

My status is awaiting EIC immediate decision and awaiting reviewer scores, it has been a week now and I don't know when I will get the results. It's really slow, I started submitting on September 6th

(0) 讚！ | hoda

Today should be submission day

(0) 讚！ | qq77qq

Hey, how are you feeling now?

(0) 讚！ | 那搁浅的梦

10.8 submission
12.5 major revisions requested, but only 7 comments and no additional experiments required
12.7 resubmitted after revisions
12.30 accepted
Thank you to the editor Yiquan Wu and the kind-hearted reviewers. The only downside is that the impact factor has decreased this year. It is somewhat frustrating to see a long-established journal like Meitao being treated in such a way by the Chinese Academy of Sciences

(5) 讚！ | NJTECHxxj

It feels like playing around, just fooling around

(0) 讚！ | 于亚杰

Is there still motivation to invest after the three districts have been developed?

(0) 讚！ | sakuraai

Just got back the editorial feedback, China is still trying to take shortcuts, no one is working on traditional materials

(0) 讚！ | 小城市

Three zones, three zones

(1) 讚！ | LH

12.06 EIC: Not Assigned ADM: Not Assigned
12.12 ADM assigned, reference modification requested
12.13 resubmitted EIC: Not Assigned ADM: Not Assigned
12.19 ADM assigned, Awaiting EIC Assignment
12.20 EIC assigned, Awaiting EIC Immediate Decision, Under review
1.8 Awaiting EIC Immediate Decision, awaiting reviewer scores
1.16 Awaiting AE Assignment
1.22 Awaiting AE Recommendation
2.18 Revision based on feedback from 5 reviewers
4.8 Resubmission for revision
4.12 Awaiting EIC Immediate Decision under review
4.14 Awaiting EIC Immediate Decision Awaiting Reviewer Scores
4.22 Awaiting AE Recommendation

(0) 讚！ | qq77qq

Submitted on October 30, 2023
First review results came out on November 12, with one minor revision and one major revision
Resubmitted on November 17, accepted on November 21
Thanks to the fast handling by Editor Qiang Fu and the reviewers

(0) 讚！ | 乔梦珂

9.3 submit
10.2 Minor Revision
10.4 submit
10.6 accpet

(3) 讚！ | Wlc

Normal process. If no reviewers accept the invitation, the manuscript will be sent back to the editor and will likely be reviewed again

(0) 讚！ | xin111

awaiting reviewer assignment about 20 days later turned to Under review, what's going on, guys!

(0) 讚！ | big栗子

2023.06.05 Submission
2023.06.22 Rejected due to high similarity index
2023.07.02 Resubmission after reducing similarity
2023.07.19 Under review
2023.08.08 Reviewer comments
Reviewer 1: 5 comments
Reviewer 2: No comments, rejected, stating mismatch with journal
Reviewer 3: 7 comments
Reviewer 4: Major revisions, 5 comments
Associate Editor: Suggested acceptance, 5 comments
Editor-in-chief: Minor Revision
2023.08.25 Response to reviewer comments
2023.09.10 Accepted

Reviewers were fast, AE and editor-in-chief were a bit slow

Thank you to all the reviewers and AE, very professional, provided meaningful comments that greatly improved the article

(21) 讚！ | LH

Hey, bro, could you be more low-key? I dare not say someone has died. My last step, "awaiting ae recommendation," started on July 18th and ends on August 3rd, which means it will take about two weeks to get the result. Keep going and be patient.

(0) 讚！ | 清水023

I want to know how long it takes for the status "Awaiting AE Recommendation" to be completed. It has been almost two weeks and there has been no progress. Is the AE no longer active?

(0) 讚！ | 青衫衫衫

I want to know the status: Awaiting AE Recommendation, how long do I need to wait? I feel like the associate editor is dead? It's been over a week and there's no progress??

(0) 讚！ | 青衫衫衫

Want to know the status: Awaiting AE Recommendation, how long do I need to wait? I feel like the associate editor is dead? It's been over a week and there has been no update?

(0) 讚！ | 青衫衫衫

I want to know the status: Awaiting AE Recommendation, how long do I need to wait? I feel like the associate editor is dead, it's been over a week and there has been no progress.

(0) 讚！ | 青衫衫衫

Hahaha, yes, my bad.

(0) 讚！ | 菜鸟qin

Actually, our situations are quite similar. We both submitted our work in April and still haven't received any results. Sigh, how unfortunate.

(0) 讚！ | 清水023