2024.3.14 submitted to the journal
2024.3.14 with editor
2024.3.19 under review
2024.3.24 required review complete
2024.3.26 major revision
2024.4.22 revision submitted to the journal 
2024.4.22 under review
2024.4.24 minor revision
2024.5.6 revision submitted to the journal
2024.5.8 returned for formatting revision
2024.5.13 revision submitted to the journal
2024.5.14 returned for formatting revision
2024.5.15 revision submitted to the journal
2024.5.17 with editor
2024.6.4 emailed request for acceptance, copyedited the same day, revised reference order
2024.6.7 accepted after revising caption
The editor and reviewers are efficient, and the journal has high standards for formatting of figures and text

(0) 讚！ | 萌萌

How long have you been with the editor?

(0) 讚！ | 萌萌

I'd like to ask how long did you take with the editor at the end. I have also been revised several times on images and formats, and now I have been waiting for a long time to go back for revisions with the editor. I am a little worried, 111

(0) 讚！ | 于秋雨

I want to ask how long did it take for your last revision with the editor. I also had several revisions on the images and formatting, and now it's been a long time since I sent it back for another round of revisions with the editor, so I am a bit worried

(0) 讚！ | 于秋雨

Hello, I would like to inquire if this journal charges a non-OA publication fee?

(0) 讚！ | mm45

In the state of system being sent for review, did everyone receive the track email? Why didn't I receive it, and I can't find it on the public account either

(0) 讚！ | 大木南哥

Is it normal for the status to change to "with editor" about one week after the revised submission? How long does it usually take for acceptance?

(0) 讚！ | 中中中毕业！

How many reviewers are usually involved in the review process?

(0) 讚！ | 小方0528

Wow, the Chinese Academy of Sciences got assigned to the first district, so lucky!

(0) 讚！ | 王珂

It's been 7 days since RRC, why is the editing process so slow?

(0) 讚！ | huanyuok

How should I pay the review fee?

(0) 讚！ | 石榴-1

Not choosing OA will also incur a layout fee starting from approximately 6,000 yuan, determined by the length of the article. If OA is chosen, an additional payment will be required.

(0) 讚！ | 2021FF

This journal is relatively slow in online retrieval and WOS indexing, and it may take about a year or so.

(1) 讚！ | 2021FF

When should the layout fee be paid? The information I have received now is that my submission has been accepted after modifications. Then, a Chinese version format instruction was given. When I submit the revised manuscript again, I will be provided with a receipt for the layout fee.

(0) 讚！ | 邵小赤

The speed is too slow, but at least there is good news.
The article was submitted on August 1st,
The reviewer's comments came back on October 28th.
Replies to the reviewer's comments were made on November 16th.
After revisions, it was accepted on December 21st.
Then there were three more revisions for image formatting until January 10th.
After resubmission, the status changed to "With Editor." It should be fine now.

(3) 讚！ | 王珂

Accepted! The subscription fee is indeed quite high. I support domestic magazines, keep up the good work.

(0) 讚！ | cryst

If it is not open source, how can the layout fee be charged?

(0) 讚！ | 两点水；‘’

2022-9-13 Post
2022-11-17 One revision, two agree, one disagree
2022-11-29 Revised format issues again
2022-12-3 Revised chart format
2022-12-10 The above referenced manuscript will be handled by Editorial office Professor Feng E Wang.
Have not received an acceptance letter yet

(7) 讚！ | cryst

Charge for page fees even if not open source, and pay separately for open source.

(1) 讚！ | BK7083

The layout fee is too expensive, 6000 for the first 5 pages, and an additional 500 for each additional page.

(2) 讚！ | BK7083

The editor's attitude is quite poor, and the payment is very expensive. There is a basic payment, 6000 for up to four or five pages, and then additional charges per page. However, it's not an open source despite being so expensive. It is not recommended to submit if there is insufficient budget.

(0) 讚！ | abcdertf

May I ask why I still have to pay the manuscript review fee for the No OA option I chose? If it is accepted later, will I still have to pay the page charge? How much is the page charge?

(0) 讚！ | 19猪猪侠

May I ask if choosing not to use OA requires a layout fee? Thank you very much.

(0) 讚！ | JMWJ

Submitted on January 23, 2022, approximately 3-4 days for review, and 20 days for major revisions feedback. After submission, it will undergo a second review, which takes about two weeks. Then, the formatting needs to be adjusted, and it may be returned for modifications two or three times before being accepted on April 21. The editing process is relatively fast, and there are strict requirements for images, which must be modified according to the magazine's specifications.

(18) 讚！ | F0reverZN

The review process is fast, with high requirements for overall quality. The reviewers are very serious, and the editors are very efficient. However, the number of articles published per year is a bit too few. I strongly suggest trying to submit it, with the timeframe provided for everyone's reference.

Feb 28: Submitted
Mar 01: Assigned to editor
Mar 03: Under review
Mar 26: Required reviews completed
Mar 27: Minor revision
Apr 7: Revised submission
Apr 7: Submitted to journal

(10) 讚！ | John Bull