How long after acceptance did you receive the proof? My article was accepted on 4/24, but I haven't received the proof yet. With other journals, I usually receive the proof within a week of acceptance

(0) 讚！ | 暖暖的暖暖

How long will it take to receive the proofs?

(0) 讚！ | 墨1

There is no need to recommend reviewers, this is the simplest submission process

(0) 讚！ | zzrfreeloop

I am preparing to submit a manuscript for publication. Just wondering, is there a requirement to suggest potential reviewers in the journal submission system?

(0) 讚！ | updexixi

I vomited, the journal itself is still fast, the first review gave opinions in eight days. I really wanted to punch the reviewer to death. I have revised three times. I thank the editor and the reviewer. Of course, I also thank the other reviewer. Thank you for challenging me

(0) 讚！ | zzrfreeloop

I am one of the three reviewers, one of them gave a pass, the other two gave minor revisions, which is acceptable, and the editor did not cause much trouble

(0) 讚！ | Pudding77

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers' opinions you have received during the initial review stage before making a decision on edits?

(0) 讚！ | SCI小猪猪

2022.11.16 Submission received
2022.11.17 Initial technical check
2022.11.25 Peer review
2023.01.03 Major revision
2023.01.14 With editor
2023.01.16 Peer review
2023.03.10 Accept

Actually, the process started quite quickly, including the first review which was acceptable. There were three reviewers, and they took a little over two months to provide their feedback, stating that a major revision was needed. One of the reviewers gave their approval, while the other two combined had only 14 suggestions. I thought that after less than a week of revisions, we would have a result. However, the editor struggled with one of the reviewer's comments and sent it back to them. The reviewer took a week to respond, but the editor was on vacation. I had to wait until March 1st, with the status showing "1 Reviewer report received," and couldn't resist urging the editor. They replied that they were on vacation until March 1st and would accept the manuscript on the 10th, once back to normal work.

Overall, this journal seems to be relatively niche, with not too many submissions. There are no specific requirements for the formatting of the layout, but Springer's new submission system is really unreasonable. If we disregard the unexpected vacation of the editor, the speed is actually quite good, and the impact factor is increasing rapidly. I hope the journal continues to improve!

(0) 讚！ | Pudding77

Is the journal demanding? What type of article did the original poster write? Which type of article is more likely to be accepted?

(0) 讚！ | IF=100

Excuse me, does this journal require a page fee?

(0) 讚！ | chai

2019.10.31, submitted; 2019.11.4, under review; 2019.12.20, major revision; 2020.1.6, the revision was returned; 2020.1.25, accept. It was okay and the speed was pretty fast.

(0) 讚！ | Simple longer

There is no news in the submission of the October 9th, 17th, and I have ignored the two times during the period.What should I do to withdraw the draft?

(0) 讚！ | xiuyansong@126.com

I sent two articles to this journal. The first review period took more than one year before my paper was accepted. For my second article, it was less than three months from submission to revision.

(0) 讚！ | 匿名