What about you, OP? How long after did you receive the official acceptance email?

(0) 讚！ | Mengli CHI

Received a provisionally accepting on March 28th, but there has been no further progress until now. Emails have not been answered either. Does anyone know what is going on?

(1) 讚！ | jianyiren

I am also like this, did you receive the final review comments? What was the result?

(0) 讚！ | ll11y

General peer review requires a minimum of two reviewers. There are two situations:
1. Initially, only one person accepted the review, and now the result of the first person is out but there is still no second person to accept the review.
2. Conflicting opinions, looking for a third person to arbitrate

(0) 讚！ | 论文中中中

Hello, can I ask what's going on? My current situation is the same as yours in the beginning

(0) 讚！ | ll11y

Submission on September 7, 2023
(The first reviewer gave more than 20 suggestions, suggesting major revisions. The second reviewer gave 4 suggestions, for easy modifications. The editor sought arbitration, and the arbitration expert said I couldn't finish so many suggestions, suggesting rejection and resubmission, with 12 months for revisions)
Notification of rejection and resubmission on November 8, 2023

Due to the year-end project summary, I left the article unmodified for a period of time, actually only spent about a month on revisions
Resubmitted in the system on January 23, 2024, along with responses to reviewer comments
Editor started processing on February 22, 2024, seeking reviewer experts
(The first reviewer should be the same as last time, and they thought I had responded adequately and could accept. The second reviewer was probably new, only mentioning unclear and inconsistent conceptual descriptions without specific reasons, likely to reject. Another arbitration was sought, the arbitrator was a member of the editorial board, and they rejected the second reviewer, believing it could be published)
Accepted temporarily on March 18, 2024

(0) 讚！ | 喵里个喵喵喵

SUBMITTED: 18-Jan-2024
DECISIONED: major revision, 15-Feb-2024

Revision Submitted: 01-Mar-2024
DECISIONED: Provisionally Accepted, 12-Mar-2024

It took a bit long to make revisions because I didn't go back to school during the winter break. However, I finished the revisions in just two days. The editing and reviewing process is much slower than APL and JAP. The articles I submitted before were accepted in about 25 days. The average time on the official website seems to be the fastest in JPD, and my time seems fast in JPD. Although slow, it is still considered fast compared to others. I am still very lucky

(0) 讚！ | XJTU-EE-K

11.07 submission
12.18 revision
12.21 return
1.26 acceptance
It took a long time due to Christmas and New Year, and I wrote a follow-up email on 1.19

(0) 讚！ | wkk1234

1.02 Review comments came back, allowing 4 weeks for major revisions.
2.07 provisionally accepted.
During this period, some information needed to be modified, so I reached out to the editor who promptly replied

(0) 讚！ | Tmt

Submitted an article on topological acoustic metamaterials on 11.05, and so far, the article has reached the status of "1st reviewer agreed to report" in the article tracking system. It has been almost two months. I'm not sure if this situation is considered normal or slow?

(0) 讚！ | Tmt

Indeed, it was mainly the reviewers delaying. I finally received the first round of feedback and have one month to revise

(0) 讚！ | 凛冬已至1996

This journal sends emails for all notifications, but the main issue is that reviewers delay their reviews, and the editors are unaware of the reasons. After sending back revised manuscripts, it always takes about a week before they are processed

(0) 讚！ | 雪落你看不见

It's normal, this journal will email when there is news. The main problem is that the reviewers are slow, and the editors don't know why, but there always seems to be a delay of about a week after sending the revised manuscript back

(0) 讚！ | 雪落你看不见

Congratulations, congratulations, finally accepted after a long wait for your previous post!!

(0) 讚！ | 凛冬已至1996

Submission to Microwave Metasurfaces
8.16
Returned for Major Revision
12.3
Revised
12.18
Provisionally Accepted
1.12
Families, tears filled my eyes. Five months is so long

(0) 讚！ | 凛冬已至1996

2023.11.27 Formal Accept

(0) 讚！ | 雪落你看不见

The format was rejected, is there any missing documents? Does anyone know the reason?

(0) 讚！ | 冬天 的雪

Alas

(0) 讚！ | Icepig

2023.11.20 Provisionally Accepted

(0) 讚！ | 雪落你看不见

The second review gave feedback to Zhongxiu, with one reviewer agreeing to accept it, while the other reviewer was extremely picky, having very high requirements for vocabulary and repeatedly scrutinizing the words used throughout the entire text, demanding very precise wording and clear sentence meanings. It is advised to be cautious when submitting

(0) 讚！ | 雪落你看不见

6-Aug-23 SUBMITTED
16-Aug-23 Awaiting Referee reports
4-Oct-23 Awaiting Decision
4-Oct-23 Moderate Revision
16-Oct-23 SUBMITTED
23-Oct-23 Awaiting Referee reports
27-Oct-23 Awaiting Decision
30-Oct-23 Provisionally Accepted

(0) 讚！ | 整天做梦

The two reviewers of the initial review requested major revisions, but I have not received any feedback after making the revisions

(0) 讚！ | 雪落你看不见

How many reviewers are there for your initial review, and what are their opinions?

(0) 讚！ | 论文中中中

2023.7.20 manuscript received
2023.9.12 major revision
2023.10.8 manuscript received with major revision
2023.10.15 awaiting decision
2023.10.20 provisionally accepted
2023.10.23 final accepted

(0) 讚！ | 阿斯顿15

6-Aug-23	SUBMITTED
16-Aug-23 Awaiting Referee reports
4-Oct-23	Awaiting Decision
4-Oct-23	Moderate Revision

(0) 讚！ | 整天做梦