23-Apr-2024 Submitted
05-May-2024 Awaiting Reviewer Selection
08-May-2024 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
12-May-2024 Awaiting ED Recomendation
27-May-2024 Awaiting EEIC Decision
02-Jun-2024 Major Revision
13-Jun-2024 Revision Submitted
13-Jun-2024 Awaiting Reviewer Assignment

(0) 讚！ | KSS

My Submission Experience

【Experience】The submission process went through 3 rounds. In the first round, there were issues with the image format, so I made modifications and resubmitted after the editor returned it. In the second round, major revisions were suggested by 3 reviewers, and I made many additions and modifications according to their feedback before resubmitting. In the third round, the editor found new reviewers who raised similar issues to the second round. After addressing each comment and making further revisions, my submission was rejected after the final resubmission.

【Feelings】If you are in a hurry to publish your paper, I recommend proceeding with caution when submitting here. The editor seemed to have strict requirements for the content of the paper, primarily based on the feedback of the reviewers. The speed of the review process could also improve. However, it may still be worth trying to submit here if you have the opportunity

(0) 讚！ | WP2022

From the first submission to repeated rejections and submissions, from initially submitting to zone two to now submitting to zone three, the journey has been truly tortuous and not easy. Perhaps only classmates who have relied on themselves from start to finish can understand the bitterness along the way. Although there is some regret, I am also content, at least I can graduate smoothly and continue working.

The review speed of the journal is normal, within the range of about three months, from submission to initial feedback, three months. It takes nearly three months from acceptance to being indexed in WOS, but mine was considered slow. I have seen that in the past it usually takes less than two months. The editors are also very conscientious, they continue to ask questions about some details after the revised manuscript, optimizing the content and presentation of the articles. The chief editor is also very friendly. Overall, it is worth submitting. Those who want to get a head start on national awards or meet graduation requirements can give it a try.

A detailed timeline of my personal manuscript has been attached, with records of each step from submission to indexing, for reference only

(0) 讚！ | 麦辣鸡翅

Published on JMS official website
10-26
Published on Springer official website-Online
11-08
Web of science Indexing：
2024-1-03

(0) 讚！ | 麦辣鸡翅

Formatting: 10-05
Returned: 10-08
Editor Comments: 10-09
Revised: 10-14
Image Mods & Forwarding: 10-15
Pre Final Comments: 10-18
Final Proofreading: 10-25

(0) 讚！ | 麦辣鸡翅

Submitted: 2023-6-13
SE Comments, Assignment: 6-13 to 6-20
EEIC Check: 6-24
Reviewer Selection, Assignment, Scores: 6-25 to 7-28
ED Rec, Reviewer Assignment, Scores: 8-20 to 9-02
Major Revision: 9-04
Revised, Admin, Next Step: 9-13 to 9-14
Reviewer Scores: 9-14
EEIC Decision: 10-05
Accept: 10-05

(0) 讚！ | 麦辣鸡翅

Here is a brief description of my submission experience

(0) 讚！ | 麦辣鸡翅

How is the article going, OP?

(0) 讚！ | 云亦如岩

Have you got any results?

(0) 讚！ | 云亦如岩

September 26, 2023 Awaiting SE Comments

(0) 讚！ | iCouldke

On the 8th day after submission on September 20, 2023, wait for him, wait for him, or wait for him!!!

(0) 讚！ | iCouldke

Submission deadline is September 13, 2023!

(0) 讚！ | iCouldke

March 10, 2023, submission.
June 2, 2023, major revision.
July 5, 2023, minor revision.
July 8, 2023, minor revision.
July 10, 2023, acceptance.
The submission experience was very good, and the teachers at the editorial department were very patient, tirelessly guiding me through multiple revisions. The requirements for figures and tables were high and very rigorous.

(0) 讚！ | 三三三三三三

The paper was initially accepted for publication by the reviewers of Landslides, but after being rejected by the editors, it was submitted to JMS and accepted after two major revisions. The journal is decent, but improvements are desired. The progress is a bit slow, as it was submitted in October of year 22 and accepted in March.

(0) 讚！ | 你好123

7.26 Modify according to pre-publishing requirements (references, figures, and table formats) and send to email jms@imde.ac.cn.
8.3 Received an email requesting further revisions, revised on 8.5.
9.4 Editor-in-chief requested further modifications to the abstract and figures/tables, revised on the same day.
10.14 Publication layout sample, publication fee of 6000.
10.16 Final layout sample.
10.26 Publishing.
11.7 Indexing.

(0) 讚！ | franthy

Do you still need to pay for publication fees if this journal is not chosen for development and publication?

(0) 讚！ | 倔强的瓜牛

Does this journal require a publication fee?

(0) 讚！ | 倔强的瓜牛

I am also in the second review, it has been over a month. Still waiting for the reviewer's evaluation. It has been reviewed twice, hoping for some good news!

(0) 讚！ | HNGUOQIIANG

I have been waiting for over 4 months for the result of my first trial, but it is still under review. I will continue to wait!

(0) 讚！ | HNGUOQIIANG

Bro, how long after you accept will you be proofreading?

(0) 讚！ | 华强的朋友，虎哥的兄弟

It has been over two months since submission, and it is still "Awaiting EEIC Check".

(0) 讚！ | nyman1000

3.26 Submitted
4.17 Revised format, resubmitted
5.16 Major revision
6.8 Revised
6.27 Minor revision
7.3 Revised
7.25 Accepted

(0) 讚！ | franthy

It should be that the number of contributors has increased. Six months ago, one could edit and confirm the submission within 7 days, and submit or not for review. Mountain engineering-related articles can be submitted. Now, when resubmitting, it takes almost one and a half months for an editor to process it, resulting in direct rejection.
3.5   Submit
3.9   Awaiting SE Assignment   ADM: Zhang, Jade
3.29 Awaiting EEIC Check
4.22 Rejected.

(0) 讚！ | DaydayBird

I am anxiously waiting for a decision.

(0) 讚！ | liugaqiang

2020-12-10 submit
2021-03-21 major revise
2021-04-27 submit
2021-05-31 accept

Translation:
2020-12-10: Submit
2021-03-21: Major revise
2021-04-27: Submit
2021-05-31: Accept

(0) 讚！ | 平/