May I ask what progress has been made now?

(0) 讚！ | QTD

What the hell are these JB, COAP, JOGO, JOTA areas? How could they end up in Zone 3? Can it get any lower?

(7) 讚！ | 研究者

The first review took 11 months, with two reviewers who both recommended revisions before publication. It has been 2 months since the second review, and there is still no update.

(0) 讚！ | 爱上做学术

Can non-communicating authors track the progress of the review?

(0) 讚！ | 酒儿m

2019/3 - new submission
2019/5 - with editor
2019/8 - under review
2020/3 - review completed
2020/4 - major revision
2020/4 - with editor
2020/7 - under review
2021/3 - minor revision
2021/5 - decision in process
2021/6 - reject (sorry to inform you that your paper is not suitable for this journal)

(1) 讚！ | renwu2

December 2018 - new submission
August 2019 - with editor (previously new submission)
December 2019 - under review
August 2020 - major revision
February 2021 - minor revision
June 2021 - reject (reason: cited references are too old, exceeding the past three years, FK, FK)

(0) 讚！ | zhiku

The submission was not assigned an editor for two months. It was assigned an editor in the third month, but got rejected in the fifth month without external review. The reason for rejection was that it was deemed unsuitable for this journal. It's really frustrating and a waste of six months. Isn't it irritating?

(0) 讚！ | 背景纳米所

The journal is indeed very slow, and I do not recommend students to submit papers. The timing is not enough. I found that the editor only works once a month. If your paper is not processed during that time, you have to wait until the next month. The editor generally handles submissions on the 14th of each month. My submission experience was roughly as follows: After submitting, it became a "new submission" because I submitted on the 16th and missed the deadline. I had to wait until the 14th of the following month for the manuscript to be returned with a request for supplementary statements. After submitting the requested statements, I had to wait until the 14th of the next month for it to become "with editor". This status lasted for three months before it became "under review". The external review lasted for six months, and then I received major revisions. After submitting the revisions, I had to wait until the 14th of the following month for it to become "with editor" again. It took about a month for it to become "under review" again, which lasted for three months. Then, I received minor revision comments. After submitting the minor revisions, I had to wait until the 14th of the next month. It became "with editor" again, and it continued for another month before it became "decision in process". This status lasted until the 14th of the following month when it was finally accepted. To my knowledge, this is the general timeline for the journal, and it is extremely slow. Even if the paper is accepted, it is not satisfying because I couldn't meet the scholarship deadlines. It is too slow.

(5) 讚！ | 任我行，

It has been 2 months since the submission, and it is still a new submission. The associate editor hasn't assigned it yet?

(0) 讚！ | 32432424

This basic version is still in Zone 2 of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. Industry insiders are well aware that this is a good journal, but it takes a particularly long time and it is not easy to get accepted.

(0) 讚！ | 认真科研

It's absolutely chaotic, what a ridiculous thing, they actually moved JOGO to Zone 4, it's really hilarious.

(2) 讚！ | 研究者

The article was submitted to this journal, and it is still under review. I hope there are good results, I don’t know why there are so few comments below.

(0) 讚！ | 认真科研

The review cycle is quite long. It took nearly one year for the first trial and five months for the second trial. However, it was accepted in the end, and it was not in vain for so long.

(2) 讚！ | zhouzhe3596@163.com

Pit, selectd for two months was rejected; after a month of submitment, the editor was started, and after a month, it was tragedy, there was no review opinion... wasting time

(2) 讚！ | 6614314674

Magazine is very good, the cycle is too long!

(4) 讚！ | Cand

professional direction of the optimization of the direction, the Chinese Academy of Sciences division is the second district.A good journal, but it takes a long time from the time of hiring to the final publication.

(1) 讚！ | 匿名

I estimate that it will take 10–12 months on average to get an article accepted.

(1) 讚！ | 匿名