I would like to ask the teachers here, what is the current level of recognition for the traditional top three geotechnical journals, Geotechnique, Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, and Canadian Geotechnical Journal? From what I see, they are not even top-tier journals in terms of impact factor, and are even placed in the third tier.

Compared to top-tier journals such as Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology and Computers and Geotechnics, which one has higher recognition?

From the perspective of finding a job after obtaining a PhD, as well as applying for funding such as the Youth Fund, General Fund, Outstanding Youth Fund, and Postdoctoral Fund in the future.

I am very grateful for any discussion on this topic.

(0) 讚！ | 万里悲秋常作客

After receiving the acceptance notification email for the paper, how long does it usually take to enter the proof stage? In my case, I received the acceptance notification email at the end of September, but have not received the proof notification by November.

(0) 讚！ | qsh7

Friend, has the time changed after "ur"? I have also used "ur" on the same day and the time has not changed, so will the time change during the external audit? x

(0) 讚！ | yzj

Friend, has the time changed after ur? I have also used ur on the same day and the time has not changed, so will the time change during the external audit?

(0) 讚！ | yzj

Could I ask if there has been any change in your status during the UR period? I submitted on the same day as you and it has been a month and a half, but the date is still the same.

(0) 讚！ | nuuui

Submitted at the end of September in 23 years
Received the first round of review comments at the end of December, replied at the end of February
Received the second round of review comments at the end of April, but the feedback was incorrect (one reviewer mistakenly sent me comments from a different article)
Replied to the second round of review comments at the end of May
Accepted in mid-August
It took nearly a year, the review speed of yysy is really slow, so if you are in a hurry to publish, don't touch it. The feedback given was very helpful, and I heard that this journal has a high reputation. The requirements from the editor were quite strict, and I had to revise the article about 7 or 8 times. Fortunately, perseverance paid off, and it did not affect my application for further studies.

(0) 讚！ | 小仵

Does CG Acta also deserve to touch porcelain with JGGE? Every year, JGGE publishes several masterpieces, which are also the journals that those who follow the hot topics can get involved with?

(0) 讚！ | dsasfdadf

Although JGGE has a low impact factor, it is a highly authoritative journal in geotechnical engineering with very high recognition. Acta geo and C&G have average quality and level, and are not in the same league as JGGE.

(1) 讚！ | GeoCC

There is no doubt that the research content of JGGE and JGRES on soil mechanics and debris flow is exceptional, top-notch, and of higher quality than top-tier journals in the field.

(0) 讚！ | chenchenchenxyz

May I ask how many days after your UR status did you receive an offer?

(0) 讚！ | zzl科研小白

The impact factor is still relevant. The number of publications by C&G should also be commensurate with the quality of JGGE

(0) 讚！ | 小叔叔

The person upstairs is really capable, what is ACTA. Does Geotechnical Engineering still look at impact factors? Are the three major Geotechnical Engineering journals controversial? If they don't care about impact factors, then they are worthless

(0) 讚！ | GEOToM

This journal used to be in the third district of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, but now it is in the second district of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. Its impact factor (3.9) is also higher than many geotechnical journals, so where is the second geotechnical journal? In terms of soil mechanics, Geotechnique, Computers and Geotechnics, and Acta Geotechnica are already stronger than this ASCE's JGGE. However, the peer review of this journal is indeed strict. The editor-in-chief has been met a few times, and the reviewers they find are all very critical and very serious. If you want to improve the quality of your article, you can try the reviewers of this journal

(1) 讚！ | 岩土老黄牛

Let me switch, I switched to engineering geology direction

(0) 讚！ | Peartree

How are you doing now?

(0) 讚！ | emoon

Submitted on November 7, 2023.
Under review on November 8, 2023.
Looking forward to good news to follow!

(0) 讚！ | Peartree

submitted: 6/20
first round review: 8/21

(7) 讚！ | LLL98

The given text has already been written in English.

(9) 讚！ | FOO

One of the top three geotechnical engineering journals, the quality of the papers is very high, but the speed is unbelievably slow. The cycle of one to two years is simply frustrating.

(26) 讚！ | HNHB

This summer vacation, I got a collaborative article published, which is slightly better than Geotechnique. The quality requirements for the article are very high, and Geotechnical Engineering is undoubtedly second to none. The other few journals are not at the same level.

(58) 讚！ | smallcavity

The following text translated into English is as follows:

First online submission was on April 22, 2021;
Under review status since April 28, 2021;
First-round review comments were received on July 29, 2021;
R1 major version was submitted online on August 26, 2021;
Final acceptance: October 13, 2021. 

Translation:

The first online submission was made on April 22, 2021;
It has been under review since April 28, 2021;
First-round review comments were received on July 29, 2021;
The major version R1 was submitted online on August 26, 2021;
Final acceptance: October 13, 2021.

(76) 讚！ | FOO

Initial submission in early February 2021
First review completed in early May 2021 after major revisions, resubmitted in early June.
First review results received in early July 2021, one acceptance, another minor revision; returned after minor revisions in mid-July 2021.
Accepted in mid-August 2021.

(6) 讚！ | Soul-mate

one of the three major journals in the geotechnical field, but the review speed was too slow, 2 articles in 2018, one trial time5 months, a first trial time of 10 months, are 1 year of employment, 1 year and 4 months published

(1) 讚！ | hanlinwang@umac.mo

feels that the other three major journals in the geotechnical field have been opened up.Is it true gold, a try to know, very popular

(1) 讚！ | 匿名

One word, slow!Someone has submitted a manuscript around, from the time of the select to the recruitment for nearly two years.However, the quality of the journal seems to be very high. It will give a lot of support to some new ideas. Is it real gold? Try it here.

(1) 讚！ | 匿名