Hello, can we chat privately, please? Thank you.

(0) 讚！ | syl2000

Can you recommend me?

(0) 讚！ | Xf1999

Could you add me as a friend to discuss the submission to IEICE?

(1) 讚！ | I~KUN

Bro, add me as a friend and let's discuss the submission issue.

(0) 讚！ | I~KUN

The 1st Review Process
Received: 2024/05/07
Review requested Report received
A 2024/06/04 2024/07/02
B 2024/06/03 2024/06/25
Conditional Acceptance Evaluation Date: 2024/07/08
The Final Review Process
Received: 2024/08/05
Review requested Report received
A 2024/08/20 2024/09/11
B 2024/08/20 2024/09/09
Accepted Evaluation Date: 2024/09/25
Non-members need to pay an additional article processing fee. If you need a referral to join IEICE, you can contact me.

(2) 讚！ | 唯一神

How long is the interval between the receipt notification email and the receipt of manuscript email?

(0) 讚！ | 野指针

A 2024/06/14
 2024/07/01
 Review completed
 B 2024/06/14
 2024/07/04
 Review completed
The Final Review Process >> Received: 2024/08/06 Reviewer Review requested Report received Status A 2024/08/07
 2024/08/10
 Review completed
 B 2024/08/07
 2024/08/30
 Review completed

Result of the Final Evaluation: Accepted Evaluation Date: 2024/09/04

(1) 讚！ | nana

Please enter the manuscript ID and password on this page. I just submitted an article, but only received an email with the manuscript ID, not sure if I need to wait for internal review before receiving the password. Can any experienced expert share some insights?

(0) 讚！ | 野指针

Please translate the following paragraph into English: https://review.ieice.org/index_e.aspx

翻译后：Please translate the following paragraph into English: https://review.ieice.org/index_e.aspx

(0) 讚！ | 野指针

I would like to ask where non-members can view the status of submitted papers

(0) 讚！ | W_55

Hello, may I ask if any expert knows if it's possible to retrieve papers on WOS after August without IEICE on them?

(0) 讚！ | 5yyy

2023.2.5 Publication

(0) 讚！ | Williamfantacy

Hello, did you submit your work? Do I need to register in order to do so?

(0) 讚！ | WAITING1

How did everyone solve the registration problem for IEICE?

(0) 讚！ | 酸奶有点甜博士1989

How did you finally solve the problem of your IEICE registration?

(0) 讚！ | 酸奶有点甜博士1989

Email Attached with Reviewer Reports: Reviewer A has examined it very carefully and provided 9 suggestions, most of which are to supplement some explanations; Reviewer B is very efficient, with only two suggestions, but they are very sharp. Two months are given to make revisions, but it actually won't take that long.

The English proofreading report is provided as a reference for modification.
(The revised manuscript will be submitted after two weeks)
>
2022/07/05 Receipt of the manuscript
2022/07/06 Review requested
2022/07/06 Report from Reviewer B received (review completed on the same day)
2022/07/28 Report from Reviewer A received
2022/07/29 The Final Review Reports have been completed, Under Final Evaluation
2022/08/02 The Final Evaluation Result has been mailed, Accepted

(0) 讚！ | 软桑

>

2022/04/19 Receipt of the manuscript
2022/04/20 Selection of Associate Editor in progress
2022/05/06 Selection of Reviewers in progress
2022/05/11 Received Report from Reviewer B
2022/06/03 Received Report from Reviewer A
2022/06/03 The 1st Review Reports have been completed, Under 1st Evaluation
2022/06/10 The 1st Evaluation Result has been sent by mail, Conditional Acceptance
2022/06/22 Comments from IEICE Editorial Committee

(0) 讚！ | 软桑

The Final Review Process

Received: 2022/06/10
Reviewer	Review requested	Report received	Status
A	2022/06/10

Review is underway
B	2022/06/10
2022/06/10
Review completed

The 1st Review Process

Received: 2022/03/18
Reviewer	Review requested	Report received	Status
A	2022/03/24
2022/05/16
Review completed
B	2022/03/30
2022/05/23
Reviewer changed
C	2022/03/23
2022/04/15
Review completed

Result of the 1st Evaluation: Conditional Acceptance
Evaluation Date: 2022/05/20

(0) 讚！ | Williamfantacy

The text translates to: "Released in advance on the internet on November 11, 2021. I used the LaTeX template provided in the submission guidelines, without a sample essay."

(0) 讚！ | tib

Do you have a sample paper in journal format? Can you share it? Thank you.

(0) 讚！ | fanzhe

May I ask how long after the schedule is announced can the advance publication of your article be queried?

(0) 讚！ | graduate2022

10/01/2021 Submitted the revised manuscript and received confirmation email from the editorial department.
10/04/2021 The manuscript was forwarded to the reviewer.
10/14/2021 Reviewer A's comments returned.
10/29/2021 Reviewer B's comments returned.
11/01/2021 Under final evaluation.
11/04/2021 The Final Evaluation Result has been mailed.
The two experts in the second round of review did not provide any new comments, and the manuscript was accepted directly. It was quite stressful during the following days because Reviewer B returned their comments on a Friday. Fortunately, my article was accepted, and I am quite happy about it.
Along with the notification email, there will also be information about the payment process. After making the payment, I was informed of the schedule for my paper on the same day, and it will be published in 2022.
Overall, the submission experience was very good, and I encountered very nice editors and reviewers. The journal is well-regulated, not too difficult, and the processing speed is also good. I recommend submitting to it.

(0) 讚！ | tib

Both reviewers were relatively mild, with the first reviewer giving constructive suggestions for an experiment. The second reviewer provided four suggestions, involving the title, concept explanation, implications of the experimental results, and grammar errors (such as the use of articles, singular/plural, and spelling mistakes). Both reviewers were very serious and meticulous, which greatly benefited me.

The biggest impression I got from this journal is its standardization, as there is a regular workflow. Except for the difficulty in finding reviewers and the uncertainty of their review time, every other stage is guaranteed to have a response within a week. The processing speed is not particularly fast, but it is definitely reliable, and there won't be situations where things are delayed for a long time.

As for the review time, it depends on individual perspectives. I don't know how long the editor gives the reviewers for their reviews, but both of my reviewers provided feedback within a month, which is quite fast. Finding reviewers is certainly easier for research hot topics. I myself "created" a problem and even had difficulty finding a suitable comparative method, let alone reviewers in the same field, so it did take me quite some time to find reviewers for my article.

(0) 讚！ | tib

2021/06/30 Post, received confirmation email.
2021/07/06 Email notification of formal assignment number, including login method for the manuscript tracking system.
2021/07/07 Assignment of editor.
2021/07/21 Found Reviewer A (2 weeks).
2021/07/26 Found Reviewer B (~3 weeks).
2021/08/13 Received feedback from A (3 weeks, unable to see content).
2021/08/24 Received feedback from B (4 weeks).
2021/08/26 Under 1st Evaluation.
2021/08/31 Received email notification, Conditional Acceptance, reviewer comments in the email.

(3) 讚！ | tib

Hello, may I ask if it is necessary to become an IEICE member in order to submit a manuscript? I understand that becoming a member requires a recommender. Is it possible to submit a manuscript without being a member?

(0) 讚！ | lily伟