good

(0) 讚！ | sirius

It has always been the same

(0) 讚！ | 我爱足球

Research and Papers

(0) 讚！ | 我爱足球

Is the status of the original poster Under Review or all lowercase? My submission has always been in uppercase since I submitted, will it change later?

(0) 讚！ | 淡淡915

It has been six months since the submission on December 12, 2023, and the status is still Under Review. Should we follow up?

(0) 讚！ | Rt_hunter

2023-10-25 Submission
2024-03-16 Minor Revision: 20 days given, three reviewers. Although it is a minor revision, there are many comments and they are very profound, requiring comparison and additional experiments.
2024-04-06 Revised submission
2024-06-05 Waiting for decision
2024-06-07 Acceptance

This journal values "new" very much, the quality control is very strict, and the requirements for reviewers are high. It is hoped that the JCR impact factor will further increase in June, pushing into Q1, and returning to the second zone of the Chinese Academy of Sciences at the end of the year

(0) 讚！ | Dr-Liu

Submission: October 2023
Major revision: December 2023 (Seven reviewers, reviewers are serious and responsible, with detailed comments)
Resubmission: January 2024
Major revision: February 2024 (Two reviewers still provided revision comments)
Acceptance: March 2024 (Editors and reviewers are fast, accepted within half a month)

Unfortunately, the submission was in the second tier, but after the first review, it was downgraded to the third tier (was hoping for an upgrade). However, the journal's quality is very good, the speed is fast, reviewers and editors are responsible, with mostly junior colleagues as reviewers, requiring some level of innovation in submissions. Many top researchers are submitting to it, and it is expected to rise to the first or second tier in the future, making it a good journal to invest in

(0) 讚！ | 东控创科

It's very slow, mine too, it's been over a year

(0) 讚！ | PlumHappy

This journal is really slow. Submitted on January 17, 2023, rejected and resubmitted on September 24, 2023, as of May 28, 2024, there is still no news, no reminders, and both the EIC and ADM have disappeared

(0) 讚！ | 刚才那个人

Submitted a special issue to TETCI in 2021, submitted in April; revised in June; accepted in July. It's considered relatively fast for a trans person

(0) 讚！ | 半吊子学生

Round 1 (Reject & Resubmit)
SUBMITTED 19-May-2023
DECISIONED 21-Oct-2023

Round 2 (Major Revision)
SUBMITTED 27-Jan-2024
DECISIONED 17-Mar-2024

Round 3 (Accept)
SUBMITTED 19-Apr-2024
DECISIONED 09-May-2024

There were two rounds of revisions, from submission to acceptance it took exactly one year. The main reason was the slow process of the first review, perhaps finding reviewers took a lot of time. However, the results of the two rounds of revisions were quite quick. 

Watching it go from a Tier 2 journal to a Tier 3 journal felt like a loss, haha, but after all, it is a transdisciplinary field. My supervisor insisted on getting published in a transdisciplinary journal when submitting my thesis. Some teachers don’t care if it's in CCF B or SCI Tier 2, they care more about whether you have a transdisciplinary journal article. If you don't have one, it's not stable. The reviewers' feedback was very insightful and helpful for the final version

(0) 讚！ | jianghuxiaoxiaosheng

Submission date: 2023-12-27, going under review directly, followed by a long waiting period.
Awaiting decision: 2024-4-28;
Rejection: 2024-5-7.
The reviewers' comments are very professional and indeed address the issues. Even reviewers outside the relevant field will generously explain themselves and point out the existing problems

(0) 讚！ | Yudl

It's only been four months, what's the rush? It's better not to rush it, it usually takes about six months to get started

(0) 讚！ | Dr-Liu

I have been waiting for my first review for four months now, but my status hasn't changed. I also sent an email inquiry, but have not received a response

(0) 讚！ | weight-qmix

It's worth mentioning that he was originally in Zone 2, but he was demoted shortly after I hired him

(0) 讚！ | gao19

The journal has good quality and focuses on innovation. The reviewers' comments are very helpful in improving the quality of the articles. This journal will definitely be included in the Chinese Academy of Sciences Zone 2 or above in the future. Below is the record of my submission last year for reference.

一审：
Submit 12.15 2022
Awaiting Admin Processing 12.15 2022
Under Review 12.25 2022
Awaiting Decision 3.07 2023
Major Revision 3.15 2023

二审：
Submit (10-05-2023)
Awaiting Admin Processing (10-05-2023)
Under Review (13-05-2023)
Awaiting Decision(03-06-2023)
Accept(12-06-2023

(0) 讚！ | 没用的阿吉

The level of this reviewer is still very high, the quality of the journal is also very good, mainly your article needs to be innovative, and in an emerging field. Training a model on some random dataset for some messy classification is not innovative and not in emerging topics, so it's definitely not acceptable

(0) 讚！ | 没用的阿吉

Reject & resubmit: Refusing to resubmit, revise according to the modification, then submit again. Basically equivalent to major revision

(0) 讚！ | itsfine

Reject & Resubmit is to resubmit after rejection.
Major revision is a major overhaul.
Minor revision is a minor update

(0) 讚！ | Dr-Liu

Re-submitting after rejection is a major revision, while early rejection is a direct rejection

(0) 讚！ | itsfine

2023-10 Submission
2024-03 Minor revision (20 days given, 3 reviewers, very helpful comments for improving manuscript quality)
2024-04 Resubmission of revised manuscript

Looking forward to good news!

(0) 讚！ | Dr-Liu

It feels quite slow, I've been waiting for a long time, and every day it's still under review

(0) 讚！ | weight-qmix

Early Rejection (18-Mar-2024)
Submitted (06-Jan-2024

(0) 讚！ | 叠叠一叠一叠叠

I am awaiting decision in less than a month, most likely it will be an early reject

(0) 讚！ | chenchengyi621

What does rejection look like, and what does early reject mean?

(0) 讚！ | ZGY必中