It has been 10 days since I submitted my work, but there is still no response. I wonder if there is any chance of success.

(0) 讚！ | Jeep先生

It's been a week, and it's still with the editor. Is it because they can't find a reviewer or is there another reason? I see others getting under review very quickly.

(0) 讚！ | 刘育朋

First of all, I would like to thank your platform for providing a communication channel, giving researchers a good place to discuss and share their submission experiences. I have a point that I need to get off my chest, the 500-character limit on comments. I hope this can be changed as I had a lot to say but had to delete a lot of content due to the restriction. It really affects the communication and reading experience when comments have to be split up. I hope the administrator can consider this feedback.

(0) 讚！ | 伴生雨

The response time is fast, and the review process is very strict. With 5 reviewers and over 50 comments, it was greatly helpful in improving the quality of the paper. We worked day and night for a month to make the revisions, and the response letter was 30 pages long. Perhaps our sincerity was recognized, as the paper was accepted directly after the second round of reviews. We are grateful for the editor's recognition of our work.

(0) 讚！ | 伴生雨

Jul 30 2024: Submit to journal
Aug 1 2024: With editor
Aug 1 2024: Under Review
Aug 22 2024: Required Reviews Complete
Aug 27 2024: Under Review (continuing to invite reviewers 21→27)
Aug 30 2024: Under Review
Sep 7 2024: Review Complete
Sep 7 2024: Major Revision
Oct 5 2024: Revision submitted to journal
Oct 8 2024: With editor
Oct 8 2024: Under Review
Oct 21 2024: Required Reviews Complete
Oct 26 2024: Accept

(0) 讚！ | 伴生雨

11.04-sub
11.05-with editor
11.08-with editor

(0) 讚！ | 刘育朋

8.8 The first draft submitted on August 8 underwent three revisions due to issues with the molecular structure.
8.20 Currently under review.
9.11 Reviewed by RRC.
9.12 Reviewed by two major reviewers.
9.30 Revision submitted.
10.2 Minor revisions made.
10.12 Revision submitted again and currently under review.
10.13 Accepted by RRC.
In summary, the editors and reviewers were very efficient. Despite the limited data in the article, the novelty of the research was recognized by the reviewers and editors. The reviewers provided thoughtful and constructive feedback, carefully reviewing all cited references and pointing out one questionable citation in the manuscript.

(0) 讚！ | jj01502

Where can I download the template? Is there any hope of getting my work published in this magazine if it is relatively basic?

(1) 讚！ | FFXXGG

Where can I download the template? For submitting to the Ivory Tower magazine, are there any specific requirements to be aware of?

(0) 讚！ | FFXXGG

There is nothing special to note, just download El's template and replace it with carbohydrates.

(0) 讚！ | zzrfreeloop

Hello, may I ask what's wrong with the format? I plan to submit to this magazine in the next few days and would like to avoid any issues in advance.

(0) 讚！ | 满眼是林

Hello, may I ask what's wrong with this format? I submitted my manuscript in March this year and did not encounter this issue. I plan to submit another one in the next few days and would like to address this issue beforehand.

(0) 讚！ | 满眼是林

Submitted on August 30th.

(0) 讚！ | Lucklyluckly

2024.06.06 submitted
2024.06.07 under review (3 reviewers)
2024.06.24 major revisions
2024.07.12 resubmitted
2024.08.09 under review
2024.08.19 minor revisions
2024.09.02 accept

(0) 讚！ | kathy_93

4.24 submitted
4.27 return to author (with hypothetical statements and basic information on polysaccharides)
5.21 re-submitted
6.18 major (given one month, multiple conversions between ur and rrc before major)
7.15 revision submitted
7.25 ur
8.x rrc (unable to remember exact time)
8.9 accept
8.11 proof confirmation

(0) 讚！ | Hot！

Thank you, sisters.

(0) 讚！ | zzrfreeloop

If using an online proofreading system, simply check and confirm the submission, and it will be okay. After submission, you will receive an email, no need to reply.

(0) 讚！ | Andymin

Sister, just wanted to ask if we need any email confirmation after submitting the proof.

(0) 讚！ | zzrfreeloop

2024-05-02 Submitted
2024-05-08 Return to author (Editorial request for revision: provide scientific hypothesis; provide polysaccharide structure information)
2024-05-10 Re-submitted
2024-05-20 UR (Invited 6 reviewers, none accepted)
2024-05-30 UR (Invited 3 more reviewers, total of 9 invited, 1 accepted)
2024-06-07 UR (1 completed review; invited 3 more, total of 12 invited, no new acceptances)
2024-06-09 UR (1 completed review; invited 1 more, total of 13 invited, additional 3 accepted; total of 4 reviewers accepted)
2024-06-16 RRC (2 completed reviews)
2024-06-22 RRC (3 completed reviews)
2024-06-30 Major (Revised manuscript deadline 2024-07-29)
2024-07-28 Revision submitted
2024-07-30 UR (Invited 3 original reviewers, 2 accepted)
2024-08-03 UR (1 completed review)
2024-08-08 RRC (2 completed reviews)
2024-08-09 Accept

(0) 讚！ | Andymin

7.19 Submit to journal
7.22 With editor
7.22 Under review
7.26 RRC
7.30 Major (Editor-in-chief + 2 reviewers)
8.4 Submit revised manuscript
8.5 WE+UR (Sent to original reviewers)
8.6 RRC
8.7 Accept

The speed of the journal is impressive. The Carbon Dream Journal has been very rewarding. The information provided here is for reference only. I am also surprised...

OK! The technical review stage of this journal is very challenging. The submission on 7.15 was rejected twice. The template was not up to standard. The problem is that the Author guide does not provide a download link for the template. The header was changed to "Carbon Dream" instead of the journal name and image. Templates come in all shapes and sizes.

(1) 讚！ | zzrfreeloop

2024.7.18 Accept undergoing a major overhaul.

(0) 讚！ | Ouyang

Hello, the reviewer said my template is incorrect, but I am using the Avery template. I cannot find the Carbon template on their official website. Can you help me with this?

(0) 讚！ | zzrfreeloop

Hello, the reviewer said my template is not correct, but I am using the template from Aisville. I cannot find the template for Carbohydrate on the official website, do you have it?

(0) 讚！ | zzrfreeloop

Hello, the reviewer said my template is incorrect, but I am using the template from Aiswell. I couldn't find the template for Carbs on the official website, do you have it? /(ㄒoㄒ)/~~

(0) 讚！ | zzrfreeloop

Hello, do you have a template for carbohydrates? I also mentioned that the format is incorrect.

(0) 讚！ | zzrfreeloop