Extremely slow, it took over a year for the review comments to come down, the review was very irresponsible, and the experimental information already in the paper was not carefully reviewed and said to be not introduced, all kinds of nitpicking, feeling that the Chinese editor still has a circle

(1) 讚！ | XLLZY

Brother, any news? I submitted on March 26th and it's still "with editor" as of April 9th

(0) 讚！ | bright19936666

Excuse me, may I ask how long it will take for "With Editor" to be submitted for review?

(0) 讚！ | JZZ

I want to ask if anyone has been accepted without the backing of a well-known author in the field?

I have also published in some top journals in the Chinese Academy of Sciences, with much better reputation than AAP, but every time I submit to this journal, it is desk rejected. I just want to gather everyone's experiences and see if it's because my research direction doesn't quite fit the scope of this journal, or if the journal simply rejects submissions from outsiders

(0) 讚！ | 过气帕布鸡玩家

Submitted on November 29, 2023, and has been With Editor until December 17

(0) 讚！ | 海波

Submission on the 26th, now it has been "with editor" for a while. How long does this status usually last???

(0) 讚！ | chenhao112

Submitted on the 28th, with editor on the 29th, and now it's already the 3rd. Still in the same state. Is it going to last long, or will it be rejected soon?

(0) 讚！ | ZZY

It's not necessarily. I worked with the editor for half a month, and then it took another month and a half to submit for review. It was rejected after two months

(0) 讚！ | JMdong

Submitted on 8.2, currently with editor for two weeks. Is it rejected?

(0) 讚！ | 辰间

There is no comparison between aap and part/trans in terms of technology. It is way too simple. Just replacing the dataset with those outdated models results in an article.

(0) 讚！ | 3606

It should be a well-established transportation journal that is on par with these journals.

(0) 讚！ | mjc

It should be a well-established transportation journal that is on par with these journals.

(0) 讚！ | mjc

AAP Traffic Top Journal, not good for recruitment.

(1) 讚！ | mjc

You are considered fast. My manuscript, "decision in process," took from December 1st to April 20th to be rejected. Honestly, I can't understand why this process took so long. The manuscript was submitted on September 20th, and between September 20th and November 30th, it went through editing, peer review, and waiting for complete reviewer feedback. This process was relatively fast.

(0) 讚！ | 36369

Is there still no result now?

(0) 讚！ | Lxh0421

1. The submission was rejected by the editorial department very quickly (within 7 days), but the status remained as "Decision in Process" for over 6 weeks. It should have been rejected, but they took over a month to inform me, which was quite time-consuming.
2. This journal seems to not be interested in research in the field of health.

(0) 讚！ | San Zhang

This journal places great emphasis on case studies and inductive research papers.

(0) 讚！ | czy

Great journal in Human Factors/Ergonomics: My first submission was in Jan. 2021, and it took 11 months with four editors and four rounds of revisions to get the paper published. I appreciate the fast turnaround and recommend this journal in general.

Translation: I had a great experience with a journal specialized in Human Factors/Ergonomics. I submitted my first paper in January 2021, and it went through four editors and four rounds of revisions before finally getting published after 11 months. I am grateful for the quick processing time and would generally recommend this journal.

(11) 讚！ | ZHLansama

The review speed is fast, usually taking only 2 months for one round. The cost-effectiveness in the field of transportation is still acceptable (if high, the difficulty is low). However, the recognition is still inferior to established transportation journals like tr-part tits jtg.

(16) 讚！ | 3606

Submission in September 2021.
The status "under review" lasted for approximately one month, followed by "decision in process" for nearly six months (until now).
The review process was fast, but the speed of manuscript handling by the editor was too slow.
It is advisable for doctoral students who want to graduate within the last year or two to not submit to this journal.

Update-
The first review process lasted for 8 months, with 4 reviewers and an editor providing comments. The final decision given was "REJECT".

(1) 讚！ | Titus_Alexius