received date: 26 March 2024
revised date: 24 May 2024
accepted date: 11 June 2024
submission to first decision (days): 75

(0) 讚！ | 云飞扬@

Second review in 10 days, directly accepted after minor revision

(0) 讚！ | 云飞扬@

In the first review, there were three reviewers, and it took 35 days. There were more than thirty comments in total, with two reviewers being young peers and very professional, providing targeted comments, while one senior peer provided more general feedback. Special thanks to the second reviewer, who wrote a lengthy evaluation and provided 19 targeted comments, which were very difficult to respond to. This reviewer definitely read the article thoroughly from start to finish (feeling like it might be rejected or require major revisions). The questions raised ranged from the introduction to the experiments to the analysis and conclusion. Never before had such meticulous reviewers been encountered, and after reading the review comments, there was a feeling of being touched and almost moved to tears. Truly, fellow researchers, have you ever experienced that feeling of being earnestly considered by a reviewer? At that moment, it was decided that regardless of rejection or acceptance by the reviewers, every question from the reviewers must be earnestly addressed. We must not shirk our responsibility when others are being responsible towards us. Therefore, we hurried to conduct additional experiments, added mathematical derivations, supplemented with more analysis and discussion, and focused solely on this task, sleeping only 6 hours a day. It took more than 20 days to respond to the over thirty comments, but after making the revisions, the article indeed saw significant improvements, becoming more persuasive and pleasing to the eye, and there was a sense of satisfaction

(0) 讚！ | 云飞扬@

Please translate the following passage into English and Japanese, and title them ":" and ":"

(0) 讚！ | 舞动的白杨

Please translate the following paragraph into English and Japanese, and title them ":" and ":"

(0) 讚！ | 舞动的白杨

Please translate the following paragraph into English and Japanese, and use ":" and ":" as headings

(0) 讚！ | 舞动的白杨

Please translate the following passage into English and Japanese, and provide translations under the headings of ":" and ":"

(0) 讚！ | 舞动的白杨

It's been almost 3 months

(0) 讚！ | 子浅

How long did it take for OP to transition from PR to UR?

(0) 讚！ | pytorch_null

The review process was very fast, with a total of 3 reviewers. Two of the reviewers provided very professional comments, and the article significantly improved after incorporating their suggestions. It seems like the review process for this journal has become stricter. Hopefully, the journal will continue to improve

(1) 讚！ | 子浅

First time submission, overall it was quick. It took a little over a month from submission to publication. Two reviewers suggested major revisions, but the issues raised were not particularly difficult. The editor only gave 10 days to revise the paper. After one round of revisions, no further issues were raised. The editor asked for minor revisions, giving 1 day to correct grammar and proofread the article before accepting it. However, be aware that the publication fee for this journal is 2400 Swiss Francs, which is a little over 19,000 Chinese Yuan

(0) 讚！ | HQJ123

MDPI Special Issue: Uncertainty Quantification in Design, Manufacturing and Maintenance of Complex Systems
Special Issue Homepage: https://www.mdpi.com/topics/5H23414FC9
Participating Journals: Aerospace, Applied Sciences, Batteries, Energies, Journal of Marine Science and Engineering, Machines, Mathematics, Sensors
Submission Deadline: September 30, 2024

Feel free to inquire about submitting to other related journals!

(0) 讚！ | imtangtang

You're also awesome for comparing POF with this awesome journal

(0) 讚！ | wanduzi

Yes, the layout fee has been increased to 2400 francs

(0) 讚！ | zmuckro

The speed is very fast, the review results will be given within a month after submission, and the revised version will be published within ten days

(2) 讚！ | Toona

Is the price 2400CHF?

(0) 讚！ | Zerob

SCI in the three districts of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, Aerospace Zone, open access journals. There are few journals in the aerospace category, with a turnaround time of 2 and a half months and a fast response rate to emails from editors, but it is a bit expensive. The academic editors are professional and provide a lot of helpful feedback for revising papers. This journal should be back to normal next year

(2) 讚！ | 不再犹豫不决

For the MDPI water journal, as long as the assistant editor's initial review is passed, there should be almost no problem. It is in a state where you can submit as long as you pay. There are two reviewers, one provided over a dozen professional comments, while the other just gave two very casual comments. Submit your manuscript carefully, as being blacklisted could mean that your institution will not reimburse the publication fee, and you may also be blacklisted by many other schools

(2) 讚！ | edvin

I hope the journal will continue to improve

(1) 讚！ | 星辰与大海

In the aerospace industry, the reviewers of this journal are very professional, offering fair and timely feedback. Normally, it takes about a month to receive revisions after the first review, and authors have around 10 days to make revisions. The whole process, from submission to acceptance, takes approximately 2 months

(0) 讚！ | 大鱼头

The speed of manuscript review is indeed fast. Within one month of the first review, there are three reviewers: one major revision, one minor revision, and one rejection with vague reasons. The associate editor suggests a major revision. In the second review, the reviewer who initially rejected the manuscript suggests a minor revision, and the manuscript is still being revised. This journal has a fast review and publication process, so it's unclear why it has been flagged. Even the self-citation rate of PoF, which also has a fast review and publication process, is so impressive and hasn't been flagged.

(0) 讚！ | 落笔

Zone 2 of the space industry, the quality is still acceptable. The key is that compared to other OA journals, the reviewers are very responsible and have provided more than 20 suggestions for revisions before and after. Currently in the process of making the revisions.

(3) 讚！ | Seanupupup

In March 2023, a total of 118 articles were published, with approximately 60 articles coming from foreign countries. The number of contributions from Chinese individuals in journals has decreased.

(0) 讚！ | carton83

Recently, a lot of SCI papers have been removed from WOS. Is there a possibility that AEROSPACE could be affected? It was just warned by the Chinese Academy of Sciences.

(1) 讚！ | skyfall7

The reviewer is very responsible and has provided a total of 15 modification suggestions throughout the process. The quality of the aerospace-related article is still acceptable.

(0) 讚！ | Seanupupup