Will this magazine still be a top journal by the end of this year?

(0) 讚！ | insect

Just submitted it, the editor replied saying they are considering publishing it in the deep-sea environment and ecology section of "Frontiers in Marine Science". Have they considered accepting it?

(0) 讚！ | paus

I submitted it on July 4th and it has been under review for a month now. Is it because the reviewers are on vacation?

(0) 讚！ | Snail1

How long after receiving it do you usually proofread online?

(0) 讚！ | echoliding

Received date: 07 Feb 2024
Editorial assignment start date: 05 Feb 2024
Independent review start date: 13 Feb 2024
Interactive review activated date: 04 Mar 2024
Review finalized date: 02 May 2024
Final validation date: 02 May 2024

(0) 讚！ | echoliding

Your boss even asked you to submit two articles to this journal, impressive

(0) 讚！ | 裴P_P裴

Submitted on March 29th, received two sets of review comments on April 22nd, one major revision and one minor revision. Submitted responses to the review comments on April 25th. On April 27th, one of the reviewers provided additional minor comments, to which responses were provided on the same day. Review process completed on April 27th. Submitted revised manuscript on April 29th. Article was accepted on April 30th

(1) 讚！ | 裴P_P裴

After submission, the Initial Validation stage has been paused for a week, is this normal?

(0) 讚！ | Biotherm

How long will it take to review?

(0) 讚！ | Marine DOM

This year it has become a top journal, the process is quite fast, for those who are eager to graduate and have sufficient funding from their boss, they can start submitting

(1) 讚！ | 骑着蚂蚁上高速

Objective evaluation: The reputation of this journal is poor, with a large number of publications and a predatory nature; if you are not in a hurry to graduate, it is advisable to carefully consider submitting articles

(4) 讚！ | 爱浓醇

Speedy review process, accepted within a little over a month by two reviewers

(1) 讚！ | 骑着蚂蚁上高速

Mid-October 2023: Submission
Received feedback in mid-November: 1 accepted, 1 major revision, 1 minor revision. Must be completed within 1 week.
Accepted in mid-December. 
The review process was very fast, with no additional feedback from the editor. The revised manuscript was accepted directly by the reviewer

(0) 讚！ | JoshJohn

Garbage in garbage, the editorial department P does not understand, must drag your manuscript, not to be sent for review, the layout fee is too expensive, the quality of the received articles is uneven, the self-citation rate is high, and the impact factor has decreased sharply. It is estimated that it will be classified into the third district next time. Predatory journals can't run away. This kind of garbage for the purpose of making money should close down as soon as possible

(63) 讚！ | onlyqqlll

Can your article be found on PubMed?

(0) 讚！ | 骑着蚂蚁上高速

Why can't I find the articles published in 2023 of this journal on PubMed?

(0) 讚！ | 骑着蚂蚁上高速

Added an expert on April 25, Xiao Xiu.
Submitted for repair on April 26.
Accepted on May 4.

(0) 讚！ | 水环境菜鸡

The speed is really fast, submitted on March 29th, and the review was completed on April 12th.
Three experts, one rejection, one major revision, one acceptance.
The one who rejected said that I used the wrong materials and should use XXX (a material that has been widely studied). Pure sabotage, completely ignored.
Submitted for revisions on April 18th, will update after receiving news.
This journal is fine except for being expensive...

(1) 讚！ | 水环境菜鸡

What plate should be selected for comprehensive geology? Deep sea environments and ecology?

(0) 讚！ | Jian

First review minor revisions, the revised manuscript was directly accepted by two reviewers. However, the editor was very responsible and provided several pages of comments. After the response, the editor provided the second review comments, and after the response, the manuscript was accepted. Both the editor and the reviewers are very responsible, they read carefully and provide detailed and professional comments.

10 Jan 2023	
Article accepted for publication.
21 Dec 2022	
Guest Associate Editor requested Corresponding/Submitting Author to revise the manuscript.
24 Nov 2022	
Re-submitted manuscript.
23 Oct 2022	
Submitted manuscript.

(0) 讚！ | 晚报君

2022.08.20    submit
2022.11.09    Minor revision by Reviewer 1
2022.11.11    Minor revision by Reviewer 2
2022.11.17    Resubmit for revision (required to be completed within one week)
2022.11.28    Paper accepted
I saw many people online saying that the reputation is not good, so I am quite worried about the journal entering the warning period.

(0) 讚！ | Bear547

I also think so. From start to finish, what was said makes people feel that this magazine is simply trash. Yet, they still go and express gratitude. It's really like being someone and doing something, is it interesting?

(0) 讚！ | 王半山

This time, it took a total of about 3 and a half months from submission to final online publication. There were three reviewers, two major revisions, and one minor revision, with a total of two rounds of revisions.

(0) 讚！ | Levern

22 Sep 2022
Submission
02 Dec 2022
Acceptance
In the field of marine biogeochemistry, after going through four reviewers, it was rejected twice and accepted after two revisions. It took over a month.

(0) 讚！ | 空想家

2022.05.22 Submission
2022.07.14 Interactive review forum activated automatically (3 reviewers, 1 rejection, 2 major revisions)
2022.08.18 Post revisions
2022.08.23 Reviewer #3 finalized (Reviewer #1 has been unresponsive)
2022.08.28 Handling editor rejected
2022.09.02 Chief editor rejected
2022.09.06 Resubmission (Changed editor and reviewers)
2022.10.21 Interactive review forum activated automatically (2 reviewers, major revisions)
2022.10.23 Post revisions
2022.10.23 Reviewer #1 finalized
2022.11.08 Reviewer #2 finalized
2022.11.09 Handling editor accepted

(0) 讚！ | Csy_ocean