Has AE given the final opinion yet?

(0) 讚！ | 椰子先生

Have you come back with your final opinion?

(1) 讚！ | 椰子先生

Have you received the review comments? Did the review take about 3 months?

(1) 讚！ | 椰子先生

2024.7.22 Submit
2024.7.23 Awaiting Handler Selection
2024.8.6 Awaiting Referee Assignment
2024.8.19 Awaiting Referee Scores

Have you received the review comments? Does the review take about 3 months?

(1) 讚！ | 椰子先生

My paper has not yet gone through the "awaiting decision" stage, but it is currently in the "awaiting referee assignment" status. I am not sure if it will be rejected. Just wait and see, it may change to "Under review" next.

(0) 讚！ | scorip QI

Hello, have your status changed from "Awaiting DE assignment" to "Awaiting DE Decision"? Does this mean that DE has directly rejected it?

(0) 讚！ | 皮皮虾打怪兽

20240711 submitted
20240713 Awaiting Editor Assignment and Awaiting Referee Selection
20240715 Awaiting Referee Assignment
20240818 Awaiting Referee Scores
20241014 Awaiting AE Recommendation
20241026 Awaiting DE Decision
20241027 Revise

(0) 讚！ | scorip QI

I am currently pursuing a PhD in Industrial Engineering in the United States. I have noticed a peculiar phenomenon, which is that this journal is highly recognized in the United States, at least not inferior to EJOR, and perhaps even slightly higher. However, its popularity in China cannot be compared to EJOR. This may be related to the professional setting in China. The field of Industrial Engineering in China is not the same as in foreign countries, at least not the same as what I know about in the United States. In China, most Industrial Engineering programs are affiliated with business schools, and researchers in this field mainly focus on Operations Management. On the other hand, in the United States, all Industrial Engineering departments are part of engineering colleges, and the research topics are diverse, with a relatively stronger emphasis on Engineering. Fewer IE departments in the US focus on Operations Management. As a result, even if someone in China is studying Industrial Engineering, they mainly pay attention to journals from a few business schools and are not familiar with IISE Transactions. In fact, if one is conducting research in the field of Industrial Engineering that is more inclined towards Engineering, this journal is considered as the top-tier publication.

(23) 讚！ | 湛然想去月球

Top journals in the field of Industrial Engineering, the journal of the Industrial and Systems Engineering Society, and fmsA-level. Each issue includes two themes, with 3-4 articles under each theme. The requirement is not only theoretical innovation but also a strong engineering application background. The review process is long, and the domestic ranking has been fluctuating between the third and fourth tiers.

(17) 讚！ | Sophisticated

In the field of industrial engineering, Tier 1 level, formerly known as IIE Transactions and AIIE Transactions. The editor-in-chief emphasizes the acceptance of articles with methodology innovation rather than method application. It requires a close integration with engineering practice.

There are generally 2-3 external reviewers, and the Associate Editor (AE) will also provide detailed suggestions in the first round. The review process consists of 2-3 rounds, with each round taking 2-3 months. The review comments are reasonable and detailed. Any good ideas or methods that have unique applications or advantages in engineering practice are worth trying.

(26) 讚！ | Octagon