Seismic engineering combined with artificial intelligence direction
2024-03-26: Initial Quality Control Started
2024-03-28: Initial Quality Control Complete
2024-03-28: Waiting for Editor Assignment
2024-04-06: Editor Assigned
2024-04-06: Associate Editor Assigned
2024-04-11: Contacting Potential Reviewers
2024-04-14: Under Review
2024-07-31: Awaiting Editor Decision
2024-07-31: Waiting for Revision
2024-08-01: Revision Received (Minor Revision)
2024-08-15: Awaiting Editor Decision
2024-08-16: Under Review
2024-09-23: Manuscript Ready for Production

(0) 讚！ | QingxuZhao

2023.06.28 Submission
2023.08.17 First Revision
2023.09.14 Revision
2023.11.26 Rejection with Suggested Resubmission after Revision
2024.01.24 Resubmission
2024.03.26 Major Revision
2024.04.16 Revision
2024.04.26 Minor Revision
2024.05.03 Acceptance 
This article has been rejected by three journals before submitting to ESS, causing a delay of almost a year. Thanks to the opportunity provided by the ESS editor, with each round of revisions, there have been different sets of reviewers, including industry experts, who have raised insightful and helpful questions. The journal is highly regarded internationally for its rigorous data, though it may face challenges in the domestic classification system due to being a comprehensive journal. Overall, while it may take up to half a month to find reviewers for the initial submission, the review process itself is quite efficient

(0) 讚！ | 月面上挖井的傻狍子

Posted on February 24th, first revision on March 27th, revised second revision on April 13th, minor revision on May 12th, and accepted on May 15th.
This journal, or rather all journals under AGU, are very strict in terms of data usage. They require authors to upload their original data to a hosted platform in the "Open Research Statement" at the end of the article, as well as add all used datasets and software to the formal citation list.
The three reviewers I encountered were all very nice, especially Reviewer 2 who is a pioneer in a similar field and has a paper with 7000 citations. The old man was very calm and genuinely seemed to want to improve my paper. He not only provided suggestions for improvement in professional matters but also gave many suggestions regarding writing etiquette. This will benefit a first-year graduate student like me for a long time. I am looking forward to proofreading and publication soon. I want to print my first colorful scientific paper and hang it by my bedside.
The publication fee is not $1800, but $2100.

(1) 讚！ | 毛茸茸的热水袋

This journal editor is very responsible, the submission system is clear, and you can check the status of articles in real time. The reviewers are also responsible! Sometimes the main reason for the slowness is that it is difficult to find reviewers now. Due to being a comprehensive journal, it has a low impact factor like JGR, which puts it at a disadvantage in the domestic ranking system. However, because it is an AGU journal, it has a good reputation and is highly recognized overseas. Many high-quality foreign articles are published in ESS. I hope that the domestic recognition of this journal will gradually increase, and its future development will be very good.

(36) 讚！ | 科研小喽喽

Finding reviewers is very slow, it takes over a month to find reviewers, but the subsequent processing is fast once the reviewers start reviewing.

(4) 讚！ | 天堂鸟5349

It is a good journal of AGU series, which is very well recognized in North America. Many articles from MIT and California Institute of Technology are published in it.

(3) 讚！ | jiutian

The results were received within a week, which is unexpectedly fast, and the editor responded very timely.

(3) 讚！ | 米老鼠

Reviewers and editors are very responsible! It has a high standard of requirements for article quality and languages.

(2) 讚！ | cugGIS

Reviewers and editors are very responsible!The article quality and language requirements are very high

(2) 讚！ | 杨杨

Journal editors are very responsible, the submission system is very clear, the status of the article can be viewed in real time, and the reviewer is also very responsible! It is an OA journal and the cost is about $1,800 US dollars.

(0) 讚！ | winner00

Journal editor is very responsible, the submission system is very clear, you can check the status of the article in real time, and the reviewer is also very responsible!

(3) 讚！ | winner00